Bynum's Steakhouse

This was my first time to the steakhouse and it was pretty epic. The service was fast and friendly we ordered cocktail shrimp, 20 Oz lobster tail, prime rib and bone in ribeye as well which come with salad and side with onion soup. Everything was fresh delicious and tasty as can be. The prime rib I ordered medium rare, came perfectly as I like. The onion soup was a too salty to enjoy but it is a come with anyway so doesn't affect my score since it is not what I came for anyway. I came for the meats and they did not skimp the lobster tail was delicious and tender. The lobster just melted in your mouth eith the drip of the butter on side. Bite after bite enjoyed it all.

This place was amazing, first time I have been here, was celebrating my Birthday and couldn't be happier, I got their signature bone in prime rib, and it did not disappoint!. The steak filled the whole plate, and was delicious our waiter was great and had a sense of humor as well. Will definitely come here again and highly recommend.Food: 5/5

Comfortable dining, great service and good food. The atmosphere is quite homey. The furnishings and dinnerware are casual which I prefer. I had the filet with a baked potato. The onion soup was delicious but a bit salty, the side salad, bread, baked potato and tea were fantastic, but the filet was just okay. It was a bit unevenly cooked. I prefer our own backyard steaks on the grill for flavor and tenderness. My husband and I paid over $100 for our meal, and it was not a bad meal, but the price just doesn't quite match the experience. Overall, I am glad I tried this restaurant, but for a great steak, I would not choose this place.

First time to dine. Traditional, old school Steak house. Sunday early evening I was able to caught the Prime Rib before it sold out. Wait staff highly trained on dining experience and bringing value to the brand. Order quickly taken, drink refills, bread, soup, salad were all brought out very timely. Food excellent, no need to drive to the downtown for me anymore. Great food, awesome atmosphere.

Our new go to steak restaurant in the city. Very causal but the food was incredible. This was our first visit and I can’t wait to go back! Photos show the warm bread and onion soup, garden salad, we had the filet with garlic butter and potato, my partner had the porterhouse, then ended with apple bread pudding and carrot cake.

Drove in from Alabama for our 18th anniversary to have an old favorite. The onion soup is always great, hot and very flavorful. We decided to share the porterhouse which was more than enough for the both of us. Ordered it to be prepared medium rare and thats exactly how it came out. Full of flavor and beyond tender.

We shared the Sirloin..it was huge..ate it the next day too!! Service was fast and friendly. Our first time and we would go back again. Only negative, bill statement is old school..so all the charges were hard to understand.Food: 5/5

Best Steakhouse in Indy! Tonight was no exception. Potato skin app and NY strip was perfect! Super sear on the steak and nice and rare inside. Lovely!

Ordered the Prime Rib and was served the biggest steak I've ever seen in my life! The meal came with bread, onion soup, a salad and a side. The price was far more than fair for the meal! Dietary restrictions: No issue with dairy allergy

First time visiting this place and I was blown away. The bread they brought to the table was fresh, warm, and pleasant to chew! The servers worked together to ensure that not only is your drink consistently filled but also will bring out food for one another. The hostess even helped refill waters at multiple tables when she didn’t have new guests coming in! Appetizer wise we started with the shrimp cocktail and it did not disappoint. The cocktail sauce had a nice nasal kick to it not as strong or as enjoyable as St Elmo’s, but definitely gave it some competition I ordered the 32 oz Tomahawk with a loaded baked potato. Normally I enjoy my steaks medium but this time around I went with Medium rare. The steak was perfectly cooked and tender as all get out! A nice pink outer layer with a warm red center. It was easy to chew and the seasoning was great even without their added steak topping options. The loaded baked potato was a healthy size and they did not shy away from the cheese or bacon bits. I did not try the soup or the salad but my girl loved them both. People were dressed casually and the atmosphere was quiet and relaxing. I was expecting everybody to be dressed up and the place to be overly refined but it was a casual atmosphere which I enjoyed. A manager took the time to ask us how our meal was going and genuinely cared about our experience. The bill for two adults with appetizer, two main courses and multiple alcoholic beverages and tip totaled $230. Overall this trip was a 5/5 for me, From the teamwork and prompt service displayed by their staff to the amazing food and atmosphere, everything was sublime. I will definitely be returning and Bynum’s has earned a life long fan. I look forward to my next visit. Thank you Bynum’s for providing us with a wonderful birthday dinner to celebrate my girlfriends special day.