Reviews
Hands down best pizza in St Paul! Been coming here since college and happily introducing our kids to it as well. It's our favorite spot for family pizza night. The seating is comfy, the food is delicious and there are always good beers on tap. The cheese bread is legendary, don't forget to try it.Food: 5/5
In its genre, this is the best pizza in the world. Even the historic Chicago tavern-style/thin crust establishments don't come close to the experience of eating a large sausage pizza from Carbone's on Randolph. This pizza deserves a place among the greats. Worth traveling for.
Best [Minnesota style] take out pizza! I like Savxx's, but I believe Carbone's is better. Their chic wings are great too not breaded... just seasoned. Parking: I can always find parking within the block. Just be careful... I've fallen on the ice 2x in last 5 years. Not a lot, mind you, but who wants to fall on ice?!?
My first visit. Friendly staff and great service. I also like the pizza. Will try the thick crust next time.Food: 4/5
I had lunch at this Carbone's and I had a great Italian hoagie style sandwich and a good beer. The food quality at Carbone's is always very good, I've eaten at many of them. The service is always great and I like the atmosphere in a Carbone's.Food: 5/5
I have loved Carbones since highschool. Great pizza! I love that it's a local shop. I was worried the remodel would change it but it's still the best pizza! The original counter is still there, but now it's a lot brighter and more airy. The pizza is still as good as ever, and you can still pick it up to go. The only way to improve this place is to offer delivery!
I grew up near here and I remember coming here as a kid. When I heard it was being remodeled, I thought they might be ruining an institution, but this place has been totally transformed for the better after the remodel. However, the pizza is the same and as good as ever. Love the new space with the bar! I will definitely be back.
Ordered a house pizza. It was thick with onions. You can see from the pick, I pulled out about 2 cups of onions on a third of the pizza. I sent note to the website for feed back and heard nothing back, so I am posting her.
Great pizza! Service was kinda slow. Music was a bit loud. Nice place. Would go back if only for the pizza.Food: 5/5
Great neighborhood place. Friendly comfortable vibe.. excellent pizza, good beer selection.Food: 5/5