Carrie's Crispies

Oh. My. God. I was driving around after I left a restaurant and I see this building, it stuck out to me because of the bright “open” sign with the dimly lit windows. I read the sign, and thought to myself “I haven’t had a rice crispy in ages”. I was so surprised when I walked in, I was greeted by Brian and Carrie. All smiles and rice crispies! They both gave me such great suggestions on their favorite ones plus fan favorites. I was so excited I brought maybe 12 rice crispies, with plans to go back soon. They had puppy chow, peanut butter cups along with heart rice crispies for Valentines Day. It was like being in a candy store and I was 7 all over again.

This place is amazing. If you are a lover of Rice Krispies then this is the place for you. Carrie's has a WIDE variety of flavors to satisfy anyone's taste buds, check out the pictures! The squares themselves are large, really large and worth the $4 asking price 3 for $10 is a better deal, trust me. These krispies have that home-made taste compared to the processed taste store brought Rice Krispies seem to have. If you're around the Tosa area check out the blue building for these tasty squares

TLDR: Our GF/DF Lemon Blueberry Rice Crispie Wedding Favors from Carrie's Crispies were one of the most talked about things from the wedding! I would highly recommend Carrie's Crispies for wedding favors, or even just for an incredible dessert or snack! I first found Carrie's Crispies at Beer and Cheese Fest several years ago in Madison, and my now husband and I fell in love with their incredible Rice Crispies very quickly! Rice Crispies had always been my favorite dessert as a child, and we agreed that we would try to have these as favors for our future wedding. When it came time to actually decide upon favors once we were engaged, my fiance and I reached out to Carrie's Crispies to inquire about GF/DF Lemon Blueberry Rice Crispies for our wedding. Brian, who we were corresponding with, was extremely helpful, and thorough in making sure we received what we wanted. We also ordered custom stickers for the favors to go with our wedding menus and escort cards. Brian did a wonderful job, and paid great attention to detail. In order to ensure freshness as well as make it easy on me the week of our wedding, Brian allowed me to pick my order up on a day that they were normally closed. Their customer service was unbeatable. The Rice Crispies went perfectly with all of our wedding paper and decor. I had guests eating them as soon as they sat down at the tables. Following the wedding, I had many guests reach out to me to ask where I had gotten these Rice Crispies from, and even asked if I had any extras! I had my first one the day following the wedding and I couldn't believe how incredible the flavor and consistency of these Rice Crispies were. We went on our Honeymoon the week following our wedding, and I took extras with me to eat in a pinch on our trip. They stayed VERY fresh for several weeks and were super tasty. All in all, I would highly recommend Carrie's Crispies for wedding favors, or even just for an incredible dessert or snack!

Go to Carries's NOW their shop is so cute and hire them for your next tasty catering need. Carrie's Crispies was the perfect choice for our wedding dessert! I love crispie treats and it is one of the first fun facts I told my now husband when we started dating. Carrie's was so fun and easy to work with from the start. They had us in for a delicious tasting and were very responsive over email. Their tiered displays that they helped setup at the venue were awesome for the ELEVEN different flavors we picked. I highly recommend the large "cake" of original crispie too - it was fun to cut and held our cake toppers AND was delicious. Our guests raved about the treats and some even tried every single flavor. We brought extras to an event the next day and they were gone in seconds. We loved them so much we are trying to freeze some for our first wedding anniversary. They are also very reasonably priced even with delivery, the tiered displays, and flavor variety. Thank you Carrie's!

OMG SO GOOD!!!!!! We have tried most flavors but the coolest is the weekly flavors! Seeing those change and the creativity is awesome. Always super friendly and adorable building!

I absolutely love Carrie's Crispies. I purchase 2 of the 48 count boxes every Thanksgiving and my family loves them !!! I also enjoy them at Tailgaters in Caledonia.

Ordered online and OMG they are amazing. Love the innovative flavors and so quick shipping

Carrie’s Crispies is such a unique business, and everything they do is tasty! After frequenting this business since they opened their bright blue building in West Allis, we knew that we wanted them to be part of our wedding day! We ordered several trays of mini-crispies as dessert, and everyone loved them! While not every single flavor of theirs is gluten free, many of them are, making this an excellent and easy dessert choice for those with dietary restrictions. Carrie’s Crispies went above and beyond with their communication, and they were willing to bring back some “flavors of the week” that we’d had previously but that were otherwise out of season; their Carrot Cake crispie is absolutely to die for! They were very fairly priced, and we loved that they included free delivery to our venue at a very reasonable minimum order. We look forward to frequenting Carrie’s Crispies as a married couple and will definitely use their catering again!

We had Carrie’s Crispies as a dessert at our wedding. The flavors were spectacular and the staff was so easy to work with. I love supporting local business, especially when they are so deserving of it.

Wonderful sweets store. Very creative treats, fun atmosphere, & wonderful selection of goodies!