Fat Sully's Pizza

This is my go to place for NY style pizza. I frequent the Broadway location but have visited every other location here and there and the consistency is always there. Food, service, staff and vibe are always right. The right amount of sauce and cheese and the crust has a bite not just soggy. Late night pizza+beer deals are a win win. Always a solid experience.

Had no idea that dally sullys had burgers. A great burger too! Juicy, cheesy and messy. Got a basket of waffle fries too to top it off.

Love Fat Sully's and Denver Biscuit Co and this is my favorite location! I love the happy hour options, and the slices are always hot and fresh. Definitely always worth it in the morning for biscuits as well!

I considered Fat Sully's the best pizza I had to date at one time. Back when they had one location. Now, 11/10/22 my last visit to F.S. was a pizza disappointment!!!! The bread knots and salad where very good. Hell I can get better pizza in Austin now. They use to be the best, west of the Mississippi according to New Yorkers that I know. I was going to relay my experience directly to F.S. website, no feedback form there.

My niece was visiting from out of town, I had not seen her for years and we were on a very tight schedule to get together. We stopped in for a slice and had a great time. Ken helped us out and he was great! Very friendly and funny. He added a little 'zest' to our limited time together. Thank you Ken. You made me a repeat customer!

Service can be very spotty here. Usually the servers are friendly and the food is good, but the kitchen is where the spotty service comes in. It doesn't take 30-40 minutes to reheat a piece of pizza with a couple of extra toppings on it.

5/5 Stars. Food was great. Great selection of family friendly games. Great service. Parking is a little harder but not horrible only side street parking. We'll be back before we leave the area. Picture is of loaded garlic knots with dipping sauces, didn't get pizza picture as we were to hungry Kid-friendliness: Games for the whole family

This place is so great. The pizza is large, and New York style in terms of crust. The cocktails are awesome, especially the one with the homemade jam in it! The salads are pretty simple, but perfect for breaking up the flavors. I especially enjoy the blue cheese dressing. They also have a great beer+shot deal for anyone looking for a cheap night out :. We go here for most birthdays and will be back soon.

Pretty damn good pizza. Solid commitment to good customer service too. They brought out our slices and said they were refiring new slices because these were too crispy. Solid move. I've been there before and will go again.

Ryan is such a gem! He saved our date night after an unfortunate experience nearby! Amazing service from all service staff and bomb food!