Mayhew Bakery

The tuna salad sandwich makes you want to slap yo momma!!! From the freshly made tuna salad, to the cheese, to the delicious honey wheat bread…it was fantastic. The customer service was great too!!

Some of the best baked goods I've had. Bread and pastries are amazing and they have a large assortment and variety. I'm honestly not the biggest pastry person but I find myself looking forward to our Saturday trips there when we buy almost one of every pastry. They started making pizza occasionally and I certainly hope they keep it up. People are very friendly. I just wish they were open more often!

I've already posted my rave reviews on this place. It is consistently good. Tonight was pop up pizza for a few hours. It was awesome. A little pricey, but it was a huge pie. We'll worth the price. All high quality ingredients, and of course a perfect crust. As usual, they were slammed. You know there has to be a reason why!

This was a really excellent breakfast spot. We tried the quiche, hand pies, biscuits, cookies, and cinnamon roll, basically everything on the counter. Try to get there early before they run out! The coffee was also fantastic. Loved this place and would definitely go back!

Tasty pizzas especially the Sicilians & friendly service... a great addition to the neighborhood; definitely give your business to this local gem

This bakery is so good, we have to limit our visits since we leave with two boxes of baked goods when we visit for a biscuit. Great pastries, fluffy old-fashioned honey biscuits, crispy crust deep dish style pizza, plus sandwiches recommend the meatball and the ham & cheese. A big plus, the pastries and cakes are not too sweet. Check it out, you won't regret it.

This morning was my first time in the store. And after having searched the city for a cinnamon roll, I finally found Mayhew Bakery. While I wished that I had eaten there to enjoy the cinnamon roll warm it was delicious from home too. It was not too sweet and just the right amount of messy. I will definitely be going back.

I am madly in love with the Ham Bam!!! Its real name is Ham something or another, but my foreign language skills are abysmal. It's ham and brie and butter on an amazing baguette. The cinnamon roll is also one of the best I have ever had. I tried the pizza for the first time the other day, and I have zero complaints about that, either. It was just a slice with banana peppers on it, but the goodness was in the simplicity of the toppings not obscuring and for sure enhancing the wonderful and tasty crust. The folks running this place are so talented and so nice. Everyone there is so pleasant and helpful. I do recommend you check the hours and current open or closed status of their social media before you go, because between a global pandemic and the most active hurricane season of our lives, ya never know anymore! And this really applies to most locally owned, non-touristcentric businesses that are making magic happen in these trying times!

I’ve only been once, but it was so great: pizza available by the slice or pie, three variety of bread loaves, several savory and sweet treats, and delicious cold brew from Orleans Roasters. Outdoor seating and super nice staff. Only downside is the limited days / hours. I’ll be back for sure!

Fantastic local bakery with kind and helpful ownership and staff. They are still getting up and running so things are a bit under-supplied. While they are fundamentally a bakery, the coffee is fantastic and I'm excited to see if they expand to include more eat-in snacks and usage of their outdoor space. Based on their limited food offering the potential is HUGE: don't skip the daily sandwich. With more eat-in options and extended hours this will be a 5star place. Very excited to have them nearby.