Percy's Pizza

Quality sucks now ; quality was better when the price was $2 ; price went up & quality went down. Nobody wants pizza crust that’s hard like a cracker. Pizza crust is supposed to be soft. Owner is always yelling, dismissive & rude ; it’s almost as if making more money has made him more rude than ever. And the shorter Latino guy is even worst than the owner ; the absolute definition of RUDE. This used to be my favorite spot not anymore. Nothing is worst than bad service & pizza in NYC. WHOLE FOODS AT 14street has a better & bigger pepperoni slice for the same price

Just go here! So good we had to have it twice. Landed at jfk around 11:30pm, and ended up at Percy's around 1AM. Had to grab a couple slices. Soooo good. As we were leaving NYC a week later, we wondered if it was just the late night eats that hit different, so we tried it again and it was still absolutely DELICIOUS!

Heard about this place since a long time. Went to taste the meatball pizza, but unfortunately only the Cheese pizza was available. Nevertheless, that was tasty too.

Some of the best pizza I have had in the city, didn’t even have to ask for light cheese. I really enjoyed this spot. Certainly plan to return!

Anyone leaving a bad review about this place has no taste buds. This is the pizza I dream of in the middle of the night. Hence this review, posted in the middle of the night. The margarita is slap-yo-daddy good.

Percy’s used to be a regular place for me. For everyone complaining about the owner, I found his temperament to be refreshing and honest. He wanted to make a good pizza affordable. And was always nice to me regardless! I miss this place!

Legitimately the best pizza I've ever had in NYC, and overall might be the best pizza I've had in my life. And for an incredibly affordable price. I would actively travel from a different city just for this pizzeria.

Great pizza and at such low prices. Worth every penny.

It was delicious and cheap . I recommend to take some pizza slices and enjoy.Food: 5/5

Affordable, fast, and good. Percys pizza defines a good New York pizza slice. Thin, almost cracker-like crust, strong layer of sauce and good cheese. This pizza is delicious and definitely worth the buck for a slice of the cheese. If In the area pick up a slice. We only tried the cheese and I would get that again.