The Fudgery

We were in town for Derby Day and decided to stop in around 4pm and to our surprise there was NO WAIT! We were greeted with a pleasant smile and offered samples of the different fudge. I am upset that I didn’t order MORE but I highly recommend and I definitely will be back! I am a sweet head so the softness and sweet goodness was amazing. I sampled the maple fudge which I enjoyed but I ordered milk chocolate with nuts and it was amazing! I believe I paid $8/$9 a big slice Parking: It was a weekend so I parked at a free meter on the streetfree parking on weekends at meter

David, the owner is a man of his words! Sis and I love some caramel apple, when we found Fudgery I made sure I was there! David made sure to have enough, him & his employee made it the way I wanted it! I live 45 mins away, so it was definitely worth the drive! 10000% recommend to anyone in louisville to stop on it, Fudergy will definitely fix that sweet tooth for you ! I’ll be stopping by every week from now on

There were only two people to serve , Friday night. Both women managed the crowd pretty fast, with patience and smiles. Kudos to them ! Ice cream flavors and taste - mediocre. Nothing special Yet to try the dipped apples

Fudge was so hard the server broke the spoon trying to get a taste sample. Poor tasting, hard and very grainy texture. Ended up getting turtles. 2 layers of pecans which was nice, but had so much salt they were practically white. Caramel also had a grainy texture. Could not even finish it. Fun looking place and the servers were friendly, but the food was not good.

It seems like a lot of people have had really bad experiences with this place. My experience wasn't as bad. I just think some of the items are overpriced, but the quality isn't terrible. I tried the raspberry ice cream and milk chocolate fudge. The raspberry ice cream was pretty good. It had a nice balance of sweetness to sourness. They give you a nice little cup to place the ice cream in. Not bad overall, almost like a sorbet. The fudge was even better. It is their specialty. They gave me a very generous serving, but the price was a little bit high. It was super sweet, so if you don't want to be overwhelmed with sugar, don't order it. But it was also rich and delicious. A note on the service, which most people seem to be complaining about. I don't think it's always like that. For me, the service was fine. It was a bit busy and we had to wait, but no one was rude or anything like that. All in all, I didn't think this was a bad place. Good fudge and decent ice cream. Employees were fine as well. Prices are a tad high.

Walked to the door at 9:45 when they close at 10 and were turned away rudely because they were “closed.” I would be a lot more understanding if this was a sit down restaurant but they serve ice cream and premade sweets which takes no longer than 5-10 minutes to order and receive the order. If you close at 9:45 put that as your hours, otherwise it’s just bad service.

Loved the guy who gave me my creamy vanilla fudge. Very friendly n definitely a spot to remember on my girls trip to Louisville I went on. Will definitely be going back. Next time I'm gonna get the peanut butter fudge but overall good fudge n I really liked the creamy vanilla fudge....Food: 5/5

We met David who was super nice. God’s love shined through his smile. We are from Florida ..this is our first visit to Louisville..and I kept noticing how the people we encountered throughout the city didn’t really smile and were standoff-ish. Not the case with this establishment. The service was outstanding and the sweets were delish. Thanks for the first “welcoming” experience so far in Louisville. May God continue to bless you and your wife of 40 years. Until we meet again

This place can get very busy. Yes- it can be pricey since it's downtown. But the ice-cream is delicious when it's summer- this place is one of the places to be. Be prepared to wait a while when it is hot. No places to sit you will have to take it outside. Parking: There is a lot of parking lots around that you can park at, there is also street parking that may be easy/difficult to find depending the time of year you go

I only visited once, and it was late, but there was still a good selection, and what I got -- the Extraordinary Chocolate -- is GREAT. At about $9 for a half pound, the prices are actually pretty reasonable, and despite the crowd we got served pretty quickly. I didn't try the ice cream, but it seemed popular and certainly looked great. If you like the sweets, you have some great options here!