Brother Jimmy's - Murray Hill

Walked into an amazing busy, yet welcoming and warm atmosphere. There were loads of games to play in the bar area whilst we waited for a seat. Waitresses were great, very attentive and friendly. Food was incredible and arrived quickly. Drinks menu was great and even better at happy hour.. Would highly recommend anybody looking for an American BBQ try this place. PS. The ribs and brisket are INCREDIBLE

2 YEARS LATER I finally was able to make my way to Manhattan and revisit one of my favorite locations after everything calmed down. Lots of changes, some very disappointing due to the Pandemic. 60% of the menu was cut and my goto mix combo of the wet and dry ribs were no longer available no more dry ribs. They only have the wet ribs so I ordered a full rack which 5 of them filled me up out of 8. The fries were super crispy just as I like em, the mac with the chicken on top on point, their baked beans delicious as well. Drinks hit well and doesn’t break the pockets. If you’re reading this review, go show them some love. Also follow me on Instagram: ThatsBangingEats

Great food and nice environment! It’s a fun place and the chicken fingers were delicious get them with the chipotle bbq. As others have mentioned, the food is pricey. Also they added a covid fee to the check. I thought that the drinks were reasonably priced though. Overall good but expensive.

Hearty and tasty southern comfort food and large selection of beers and special soft drinks. The fried chicken is a go-to, perfectly seasoned. Their corn bread is house made and is a must. Great atmosphere and location

I had the hush puppies and the Sloppy Jimmy sandwich. Both were really good, but not quite amazing. The hostess and waitress were both friendly and attentive. I went at the tail end of lunch hour so the place wasn't very busy.

Good bbq food. Went for lunch and had the Dixon chicken sandwich fried chicken. It was tasty, but a little too sweet for my palate. They offer free dining for kids under ten, have bar games, and trivia nights on Monday.

Great place for lunch. The staff were friendly and courteous. A very laid back environment with good food. I felt nostalgic ordering The Sloppy Jimmy... packed with flavor.

I really like Brother Jimmy’s, i’ve already vidited other 2 of the Manhattan location. It was my first time in the one on Lex & 31st. The manager Emily is amazing, so helpfull and accomodating. The place is big and has this southern vibe. Food is also good. The restauranf is a sport bar as well and offers sliders and kids menu. I will definitely go back!

Really pleasant atmosphere. Food quick fresh and pleasant. Monday are a Beauty 2 hours unlimited wings,bbq ribs and Coors light . I stick to the wings Overall great place to come and spend some time with friends

The Cleveland Browns Backers in New York City host all Browns game here every Sunday in season. It's also a NYC Cavs bar and NYC Indians bar for playoff games. Awesome bar, great beer selection on draft, a very friendly and professional staff plus some really delicious BBQ.