Caplinger's Fresh Catch

First time eating here and I will definitely be back. Had the catfish and gator bites and the filets were huge. If your craving some awesome catfish, give this place a try!

The food is good, but oddly enough the picture for the store is wrong.... I am seeing the back of the building where we do not eat at! : So as with all stores that sell fish, you can have it prepared multiple ways, I prefer baked. The clam chowder is good, but just not enough. :

The food was great. Had the fish n shrimp platter w/cornbread n glazed sweet potatoes. So worth it. Had one of the cookies, n it was awesome!!Food: 5/5

Lived in Florida for 35 years but the best Shrimp Poor Boy I ever ate I eat at Cap's every time I show up. Best Seafood in Indianapolis.Food: 5/5

Good place with nice selection of seafood. Alligator tails were good

The staff is great; very kind and helpful! Miss Ruthie is absolutely AMAZING! The food is VERY FRESH and DELICIOUS!!! I was very, VERY pleased and will be returning for the 3rd time very soon!!!

The reason I rated a four is because, the point's that you earned isn't accurate. And they stop selling . Today food was okay Fish was a little soft not enough seasoning and greens tasted like Glory greens. Looks like all new staff since the last visit. All staff was very pleasant, dinning area very clean, also great music. Although I wasn't very happy today I will go back because they are the best in the city that I've tasted thus far.

Great food. Relaxed atmosphere. Nothing fancy about this place but food is great and staff is friendly. It's a clean casual place to eatFood: 4/5

I called in to place my order and was pleasantly surprised to hear the accent of the darling man that answered. I don't know his name, where he's from or how long he has been back at Caplinger's but, as soon as I heard his voice, I knew two things. One, that our order would be correct and two that the food would be great. I don't know his position there but, when he's there, the food and service are always awesome! As expected, our order was correct, it was ready when promised and the food was delicious! The perch, basa, alligator bites and all the sides were cooked perfectly. Thank you so much for making my boyfriend's birthday dinner experience a good one. Side note for those ordering take out, we have always placed our order before 5 PM. Especially on Friday and Saturday when they are the busiest. We've always gotten our food when promised without a long wait. Also, remember it's FRESH food, cooked to order. Not FAST food that has been precooked.

Very good. Usually a long line, long wait but worth it. We have had the blackened salmon, cod dinner and lobster rolls.