The cookies were moist, soft and good. I guess since the menu changes frequently, your milage may vary. The photo includes the 3 cookies from the week of 8/20/23. Out of this batch, my favorite was the Stroopwaffle. I'm not a huge fan of chocolate, so the other cookies didn't fancy me as much, but they were still good regardless. Definatly recommend stopping here if you're craving something sweet.
Only have 3 cookies to choose from. They rotate weekly. I had a brownie with peanut butter cookie and soft serve ice cream. You can add cereal toppings I chose chocolate pebbles. Because of the specialty cookie of the week, they also had chocolate syrup and caramel syrup on hand, but I was told that's normally not the case. You can order milk with your cookie. However, I did not. I would say they are a bit overpriced for the taste, but still a decent cookie. The cookie was not as warm as expected and was hard around the edges, where it was difficult to break apart with a spoon. For one cookie and ice cream, I believe I paid 9-10 dollars. My total for 2 was 21. It's a unique experience to try while in Salem. They have outdoor seating, jumbo jenga, and cornhole. I visited during the afternoon hours.
Discovered this place walking passed it on our recent trip to Salem. although i did see it during my search for restaurants prior to As soon as you walk in, the place smells amazing. The woman at the counter was friendly and super informative about what they offered. My husband and I ordered the dunkaroo cookies and he got the lemon oreo cookies and vanilla soft serve in a cup. I also got iced coffee with their dream cream. We were in instant heaven at first bite. My husband was literally speechless. LOL. The cookies were warm and gooey inside. The break apart was satisfying. I highly recommend the dream cream. Its cinnamon and vanilla creamer and I didn't even need to add sugar because paired with the cookie it's the perfect balance. Please visit this place, you will not regret it.
Fantastic baked goods with a shifting menu to cookies after 2pm! The baked chubby balls of goodness are filling and delicious. The afternoon cookies are fantastic, the best is the cheesecake cookie. Yes its a bit pricey, but for a treat once in a while its worth it!
Walking in Salem during an October night and came across this spot. Line was out the door but was moving pretty fast. The smell of the fresh baked cookies were mouthwatering. Purchased the Cookie Flight 3cookies for $10 which were scrumptious!!
This experience was fantastic. It was my favorite part of my Salem day today. We got the cookie flight so we could try all three and it was heavenly. It rivals my all time favorite cookie bakery at home. It is a MUST try. The only thing I would suggest is adding Oat milk to the menu. 10/10.
Good Night Fatty in Salem, Massachusetts, is an absolute gem for dessert enthusiasts like myself. I've had the pleasure of visiting this delightful establishment several times, and it never disappoints. What sets Good Night Fatty apart is its imaginative and ever-changing selection of sweets. From warm, gooey cookies to decadent brownies and other delectable treats, there's always something new and exciting to try. The flavors are rich, and the quality of ingredients is evident in every bite. Beyond the mouthwatering treats, the ambiance of Good Night Fatty is equally charming. It's a cozy spot with a welcoming atmosphere, making it perfect for catching up with friends or satisfying your dessert cravings after a day of outdoor adventures in Salem. The staff at Good Night Fatty deserves a special mention as well. They're not only knowledgeable about the menu but also genuinely friendly and eager to ensure you have a great experience. If you find yourself in Salem, I highly recommend paying a visit to Good Night Fatty. Whether you're a local or a tourist, this dessert haven is a must-visit destination. Be prepared to treat your taste buds to some of the most scrumptious desserts you'll ever encounter.
- The cookies were amazing, super fresh and had really good flavor. - The place was clean and organized. -The staff were all friendly and helpful. - Prices are not that bad for the area. - Plenty of seating if the place is not extremely busy. - overall a good first experience. I'd recommend this location.
Great cookies and other things. I had their vegan lactose free ice cream; excellent. Fun yard to relax, play games.
Nice place, cute little courtyard to sit in. Not a huge selection, and it's vegan ice cream, not sure if that well known or not, but that's fine with me because I have to have dairy free ice cream.
