La Herradura

Great to take someone on a date. The ambiance was nice, the menu had many choices and the services was great. We went for lunchtime and it was not crowded. We were able to get a parking space a few stores down, bit depending what time you go you may have to walk, but not much.

Drinks were strong and food was good. We went Cinco De Mayo, line out the door when we left but plenty of seating at 5 pm. I had the vegetarian enchiladas which were rolled with lightly cooked vegetables, unusual but healthy. Nice rice, beans, the wraps are authentic and I loved that. I didn’t feel like as though they had gone into stop and shop and had gotten a taco kit. My friend had Chilies Releos which were mild at her request and yum. We made the mistake of ordering a second margarita but they were big and next time I will pace myself. They are $14 apiece for the regular no ice with salt rim. That is what bumped up our bill. Don’t regret it, we also had the guacamole which we both voted excellent. They bring you chips and salsa right away and the food comes fast.

We came here for the first time as a family and will never go back. We waited exactly 55 minutes to be waited on once we were sat down and the place wasn’t even busy. And I can see why they barely get any customers because their service is HORRIBLE. Once we placed the order for the food, it never came, literally. The cups were dirty which is unsanitary and the menus were very old and outdated. No one ever checked in after bringing us our drinks. The hostess didn’t seem to know where to seat us and seemed very disoriented. The drinks were horribly made and the water tasted like the faucet and I can clearly tell they don’t take any measures to purify the water or at least filter it. We left before the food even came, it clearly never was going to come. As frequent people who like to try new places and eat new foods, this place will never come back as an option for us. Not worth the time or money.

The food was delicious, drinks are great but can be a slight better! Overall the experience was great although they are short staffed. I paid online never saw my waiter after getting the bill.Dine in: YesOutdoor seating: NoTakeout: NoDelivery: NoCurbside pickup: No

Waiters and witnesses were great. Drinks were awesome definitely come back when we want to have a few drinks. Food was amazing and a lot of it. Menue selection seem to go on forever, could not figure out what we wanted to many choices. In the end we ordered way to much food plates were oversized but no complaints

Nice scenery but was disappointed with how long it took my food to come. Cold and was not asked it my meal was good. Would try again but probably not on a busy nightFood: 3/5

I did not want to write this review, especially considering that my family and I dine here every week. However, I must warn people about our experience tonight. A member from my party called several hours ago to make a reservation for tonight at 7:00 PM. At 6:42 PM, we received a phone call asking if we were still coming or not. We arrived on time only to discover that the reserved table was given away. My party had to wait 30 minutes when we made a reservation several hours prior. I acknowledge that it is the weekend, but I do not understand the purpose of making a reservation. I would advise people to take caution if making a reservation at this establishment.

Excellent food and great value. Lunch special for $9. included LOTS of food. Mini burrito, enchilada, rice & beans, chips & salsa. Service is great too.Food: 5/5

My first time here. The food was good. I had the ribeye.Food: 5/5

Finally able to check this gem off of the wife and I’s bucket list. So happy we did! The food was excellent. We are in Mexico often and always look for that authentic flavor. Living in Scarsdale we struggle finding a place La Herradura. If your considering Mexican for dinner we implore you to hop in your car, uber or bus and get here ASAP. The staff is polite, attentive and were there at just the right time to help make the dinner that much better.