The Cookie Cutter Store

Wonderful selection of cookie cutters and decorative sugars that I've never seen before. Nice additions to our collection. I was a little surprised at their customer service. I was the only one in the store - was not greeted when I walked in nor thanked for my purchase.

The store is so cute and fun to explore despite its small size. I bought a bunch of mini cookie cutters for pies, and the selection is impressive. My wallet dropped out of my purse while I was shopping and I was frantic, but the folks behind the counter were awesome and helped me find it. Easy five stars!

Lovely cookie cutter kitchen shop for all your favorite & personal holiday needs....

Fantastic selection of cookie cutters, sprinkles, baking tools, etc. at reasonable prices. The owners are very nice & willing to help with any questions or to help come up with ideas on how to accomplish hard to find cookie shapes. Well worth the 30 minute drive from my house 45 minutes in traffic! If they were closer to home I'd probably be in there every other week with all the great stuff they carry! Highly recommend this wonderful store!!!

My wife and I go to Cedarburg once a year on our anniversary. This is one of our top two or three shops. Great for hard to find baking items and Christmas giftes.

Love this place!! If anyone is looking for the perfect gift for people who bake this is THE store to shop!! 100s of quirky cookie cutters that you can actually see and touch before buying. Also locally made "cheater" frozen cookie and bread doughs that help those who want fresh baked yummies but are pressed for time!

What a lovely place for someone who likes to bake. It has everything you didn’t know you needed.

Great for bakers!! Endless cookie cutters and sugars!!

I like to stop and get cookie dough as a surprise for my customers kids. Great selection so I always get several kinds of cookies

Love the frozen items to take home. I get my Christmas sugar cookies here every year. The turnovers are a delicious and easy dessert for any occasion.