West Islip Bagel

Amazing bagels, both by themselves and as a breakfast sandwich. Good amount of seasoning on the everything bagels, soft, and flavorful.

Meh... egg sandwich was just ok. Bacon was kind of a mess, some of it was overcooked and some of it was just fat. Bagel was decent but nothing I would write home about. I went out of my way to try this place based on the rating, but I honestly don't get it. I wouldn't go there again since there are better options nearby.

Great priced bagels, extremely generous on the cream cheese, however their breakfast sandwiches are nothing special.

Great staff. They friendly and nice. Loved their bagel.

You know the bagels are good when there is a line out the door. Well worth the wait.

You can count on this place being open during most storms. They have a pretty good selection of meats for a bagel store and that comes in handy when it's later in the day. Great selection of drinks with a pleasant and informative staff. Lobby can get tight when it's busy!

Great bagels! I recommend the French toast bagel. The only issue I had is no seating to eat there . But it's still very good!!!

Love West Islip Bagels! Bagels are always fresh, and the have great veggie cream cheese. Excellent customer service as well

Great bagels made on premises...get them while there hot

This place has really good bagels. The typical selection. Egg sandwiches are made well and the bagels are fresh. It's a small place but don't let that stop you from going. They staff enough people to get you taken care of quickly. The parking lot is atrocious! Very crowded, tight and people in too much of a hurry to be kind. Park in the street for a more pleasant visit. There isn't an area to seat and eat here.