Why Not Pie

The butter crust berry pie was terrific! Can’t wait to try the shortbread crust variant. The shortbread cookies are AMAZING! Found tasty shortbread as we had in England, well, this is the best!!! Buckwheat cookies are a healthy and tasty surprise, the chocolate was fantastic and they were not too sweet! The breakfast cookie is wonderful! Ordered a few times already and will be ordering again!

I'm not even a pie person, but this place has my mind changed. We had the raspberry strawberry with a lemon pastry crust. These pies are absolutely delicious. Can't recommend enough!

Everything is a delight with tasty homemade and loved recipes. I never doubt trying anything new just as ordering my favorites. I order for special events and family/friends love them. Easy ways to lay and pickup. What a joy Why Not Pie gives to myself and those I care for.

I've ordered many pies from Janice as gifts to others and gifts to me. I love that she sources her tasty pies from local farms. They're delicious and a special treat.

Janice is so easy to work with and super accommodating. I’ve ordered her pies on many occasions for several years now and have consistently been impressed by all of her items. She’s my Thanksgiving, special occasion, and gifts for Michigan friends baker.

I purchased 3 pies for Thanksgiving - Apple, Pumpkin & 3 Berry and everyone enjoyed them. Rave reviews on how great they tasted, how fresh they were and the crusts were the best they have tasted before. Thank you Janice! I will tell all my friends and will be ordering again. Excellent!

Her Blueberry ie with Earl Gray shortbead crust is the stuff of legend. Presidents should serve it at diplomatic dinners in the White House. One of the best pies I've ever had.

I had the peach pie and the strawberry rhubarb pie for my birthday celebration. They were wonderful--they showcased the fruit, and were not too sweet. Some people might want them to be sweeter, but we had them with ice cream, and they were perfect.

My father-in-law brought a pumpkin, berry and apple pie for Thanksgiving - AMAZING!!! Best pies I have ever had don't tell my Mom

I recived a lemon cream pie as a gift. It's amazing, it's so good... tart, creamy, refreshing and lite. Why Not Pie will be our goto pie shop!