42nd Street Bagel Cafe

Delightful experience here! Atmosphere of the place was a nice surprise. Then the bagels arrived, and they were amazing. I ordered the Lox... It was devoured immediately. My S/O got the everything bagel. Also very delicious. I don't recall bagels getting me this enthusiastic. Really looking forward to return.

Omg. If you want to have a really good home baked bagel you have to go here. One of the best bagels I ever had. Nice outdoor patio and great staff. I usually don't give a five unless a place deserves a five star review. This is a five.

Claremont is a very popular place on the weekends and it is difficult to get a table at most of the restaurants for breakfast/brunch. So, I decided to try this little take-out place. They have a decent patio and excellent coffee. I had their breakfast scramble bowl and a cinnamon-raison bagel with butter. Everything was delicious and only $13 with tax for my breakfast including coffee. I sat on the patio and enjoyed the lively view of people out and about on a Sunday morning.

I usually enjoy every place that I eat at in the village. This is not one of them though. Given the reviews and talk of this place, I felt let down. I had a egg, cheese, bacon bagel sandwich that was very bland. Cinnamon raisin bagel was not that good either unfortunately. Honestly, I could get a better bagel at sprouts. Cinnamon twist was good tho, especially dipped in cream cheese.

This place pre pandemic was so good! My last few visits sadly were subpar and may have been my last. The lox spread tasted like they waved some lox over the cream cheese and hoped it picked up the flavor. I ordered toasted with butter and got so much butter, the bagel actually was floppy. I always would order 3 or 4 bagels and they were all inedible. Had this happened once, I could understand- everyone has an off day - but 3 out of 3 is Not ok

Sorry that I cant support this local business. They produce a taste free bagel that is usually underdone. I have given the place 5+ attempts and they failed to deliver. I will continue my quest for a decent bagel properly baked.

Great place to start a wonderful day. I tried most of bagels there, and all of them were delicious

Best bagels around! Whether grabbing a tasty bagel...or 6...and a coffee, or relaxing with friends over one of their fantastic sandwiches, 42nd Street Bagels is the can't miss spot in Claremont's village area.Food: 5/5

Enjoyed an egg salad bagel sandwich on a toasted cheese and onion bagel. Boyfriend had the egg bagel with plain cream cheese. I really enjoyed their egg salad, which was not whipped nor overly chunky, and found the cream cheese tasted homemade. Because I’m picky, I asked about the texture of the egg salad and they even offered a sample. That was very nice. Service was also very friendly. One thing I didn’t enjoy was the bathroom stick unhygienic and no WiFi. We had to go to a second business down the street to do a little work. All in all, I would go again. Thank you!

Location good, Parking is okay, Service is good, Interior was okay, Pizza Bagel was good, Coffee was really good. Price to food ratio is good. Overall I would go back...