Reviews
Exceptional, delicious and authentic organic gelato. The flavors were so real and texture was amazing. Great prices and decent portions. A top 5 in NYC for me for sure. They had 18 flavors 6 vegan, with classical and some innovative ones like blueberry cheesecake, salt and butter, olive oil, grape etc. They allow sampling and the prices were decent $8 for 3 scoops. I got the chocolate hazelnut, blueberry cheesecake and the special concord grape sorbet. All three were amazing, especially the grape sorbet. Will definitely comeback for more.
The lady who served us the gelato was kind. We were able to sample before placing the order. My son usually does not eat any sweet, but he loved the lemon and mango flavors. $5.50 and $6.50 for the kid and small sizes. Those sizes were good enough as our after dinner deserts.
Butter and salt flavor?!?? How could I not try such a unique offering? It was extraordinary! Never tasted an ice cream flavor like this, yet the taste itself was comforting and familiar. Sent me to a simple comfortable place, a place Ive never been but know is out there. Maybe a small little-known Italian town where only Italian is spoken and the people are warm and nice. A place with no tourists and loudness. One with travelers, serenity and goodness. Seekers of life. Holders of perpetual curiosity. Dreamers. Smilers. Lovers. Hopers. A place of love and celebration… thats where your butter and salt gelato took me.
Best pistachio gelato hands down!! Love their fig too when it’s in season. Fresh, no preservatives and just freakin’ delicious. Totally worth it.
Probably the best gelato I've ever had!! They allow taste testing and the fruity flavors are to die for
My favorite gelato in Park Slope. The flavors are unbelievably rich and they're all consistently good. The employees are really nice and very generous with the portions.
they had some of the best gelato i've tried in the us - i got the pistachio, olive oil and pumpkin flavors and they were all wonderful i had sampled some of them beforehand - portions are large and i can't wait to try more flavors!
So let me breakdown my rationale for my review in two separate components: Gelato: Unique and deliciously-tasting flavors with a large variety to choose from! The pear and grape were some of our favorites since you can literally taste the actual fruits in the creamy gelato. I definitely recommend coming here for the unique flavors and I promise you won't regret it! Now if the gelato deserved such praise, why is it only 3 stars? Service: The lady at the gelato counter was visibly irritated and made sure to sigh out loud multiple times whenever we asked for something, whether it was to get a bag to carry our ice cream pints to-go which seem like something you wouldn't need to even ask if you're purchasing multiple pints..., or to try a few flavors to see which one we liked the most we tried 4, which I would like to think was not too unreasonable. Her dissatisfaction-ridden facial expression and her dismissive attitude really makes this sweet experience extremely bitter, which is so unfortunate because I heard the other lady was so kind, sweet, and even offered our friends more flavors to try just so we know what to get the next time we come back. So overall, if you just want to get your gelato-fix and don't care about service, definitely come and try their flavors before they close down for the season! If you do decide to give this place a try, I hope you get to experience the kind, sweet lady who makes your heart warm despite eating cold and delicious gelato! Thank you for reading and good luck! : P.S. The unpleasant lady worked the night shift on October 27, 2022, I just don't want the owners who read this to blame the wrong staff just in case :
Delicious high quality gelato! They always have amazing curated flavours. I especially like when they have savory options like salted butter, arugula, olive oil, etc. The only slight problem is that their portions are ABSOLUTELY ENORMOUS. I usually order a kiddie cup or cone and ask them to just give me half what they normally would scoop.
The gelato is great! I have been twice and would definitely come again to try a different flavor.