Pino's La Forchetta Pizzeria

extremely disappointed. was a regular customer. I always order Alfredo but this time it happened to arrive completely undercooked. As you can see, the picture on the left, it looks like a soupy mess. I ended up having to reduce the heavy cream myself. I called to report concern regarding the food being undercooked & was told they would remake the food for me. Upon arrival, the delivery driver proceeded to yell at me requesting to give him the dish I initially received. I let him know that I had “recooked” it & he proceeded to yell at me. I am not sure what exactly what wrong but I provided him with the cooked food & he left. Not sure I’d recommend in the future.

I was working on Valentine’s Day & needed to treat myself to some pasta so I ordered Shrimp Scampi from here. I was excited that the pasta was delivered in a pizza box. Everything was secured and no leaks were there! They even included cheese in addition to the utensils. The portion was great and it was a great ratio of pasta. The only downfall was that it was way too lemony for me. It was just very overwhelming, I even removed the lemons that came on top. There was garlic bread and it was seasoned well, but it was just a bit too hard to my liking I like soft bread. I feel like it could’ve been that batch and I’m willing to try again!

My favorite pizza place in the city. I used to go here all the time for lunch, followed by an 8 year hiatus, came back, and was glad it was as great as ever. While the regular pizza is great, I highly recommend their Buffalo chicken slice.Food: 5/5

Lunch special 6.50 cash only.. Understandable. But charge 950. For the same exact thing for using a card is ridiculous. 50% increase for a 4% fee..? Lost a everyday customer. Hope the 3 dollars was worth it.Food: 3/5

I went in person twice it was delicious, ordered online around 5 times. The 1st two times it was good- However, the last three times it has been disgusting! 1st time- Under cooked pizza disgusting, 2nd time missing garlic in the chicken francese gross tasted like bitter then ordered a personal Sicilian today it was sour garlic knots slightly undercooked as for the chicken roll was afraid to taste it. I will NEVER order from this place again!!! 3 times is wrap! A waste of money and food!

The food is great, but the service is lacking. Ordered food and sent teenagers to pick it up. Teenagers returned without the desert, even though they complained that they were missing an order. Parental unit had to go down and demand for the food, which the workers did. Not sure why the restaurant had to do that. Not going again - other places for pizza close by.

Pizza was really good, one of the best I've had in NYC. The pizzas in NYC are typically a little too salty, and I didn't run into this problem here, which was a pleasant surprise. The staff were also very friendly and courteous.Food: 5/5

I’ve ordered delivery with Pino’s a few times before and have enjoyed their food overall the previous delivery I ordered was a perfect pie. But unfortunately, my most recent experience was bad. I ordered garlic knots and a personal pie with pepperoni and anchovies pictured below. I ate half the pizza and all the garlic knots. Everything tasted fine, but about six hours later I felt nauseous. I’ll spare the details but I had a mild case of food poisoning, I believe attributable to the anchovies. I want to give them the benefit of the doubt here but in good faith I am sharing my experience as a precaution. They are hit or miss it seems these days, given other recent reviews.

The buffalo chicken slice was on a thick slice of bread, not pizza crust, and had whole slices of cheese on top that weren’t even properly melted. One of the worst slices I’ve ever tried.Food: 1/5

By far the best pizza I have ever had. Very flavorful and delicious. Premium ingredients are used to make food at Pino's.Food: 5/5