Oyster Bay Sports Bar & Grill

We ordered [to go] 2 fish baskets (1 grilled 1 fried) I substituted my fries for red potatoes, and we got a appetizer of calamari. Before we even left the parking lot, the car was filled with this horrible, rotten smell coming from the calamari. My boyfriend took it back inside to give it back. They offered to fix it, so he let them, however it wasn’t much different. The grilled fish was so salty that no one could eat it, and the fried fish was so over cooked, I had to tear off the super hard bits so I didn’t crack a tooth. The tarter tastes like straight mayonnaise. The red potatoes and hush puppies were very good, but not good enough to make up for such a terribly stinky appetizer and very poorly cooked entree. I hope this was just a one time thing because if this happens regularly, Oyster Bay might lose a lot of customers.
1 7 years ago (03-06-2018)

The best oysters! The grilled Captain's platter was delicious. I'm so glad they have a grill or fried option. Side choices included healthy options as well. Definitely a party atmosphere. Would have given a 5 star if the price matched the amount of food given. But would go back for more oysters!
4 7 years ago (03-03-2018)

Dive bar and seafood restaurant that has good food and is close by the house. Simple no fuss. About the food and drinks...and prices.
5 7 years ago (20-04-2018)

Best drinks with a kick after one I was buzzed lol The Aquaholic was my favorite, but the Tropical Blast is another great experience with a unicorn punch lol. I love the rocafella oysters, catfish, crab boil, and buffalo shrimp basket. This little ducked off spots in Columbus is one of my go to spots. Great music, friendly staff, and oh yes they have phenomenal drinks lol😘😍
5 7 years ago (09-04-2018)

Cheap drinks. Pretty much that's it. The food is ok. I once had a server fall asleep taking my order. Great drink specials.
3 7 years ago (24-02-2018)