Reviews
So it's like this. I have gone to Paddy Reilly's about four times in my life. These four times were just about the greatest times you can have in a bar. Yesterday I went there to see a friend off to Spain I would up having a spirited conversation with two guy I'd never met about which borough has the best Italian sandwiches. The more people we talked to the greater the conversation grew. The man who owns the bar is a gem of guy. The beer is cold the liquor is proper the door rattles when it swings cause there's no stopper. Thought of this three Dewars and water in. Leave your ego at the door and enjoy a night of festive live music and dancing.
One of my favorite neighborhood spots with good beer, chill vibes and at times live bands. There are darts and pool table in the back. Tip: if you have a no fuss chill date not the 1st date, bring them here for a casual hangout
Decent Irish pub with plenty of Guiness and a couple of other draft beers. There's a pool table at the back and a small stage for live music in the evenings. Friendly bartender and decent happy-hour pricing.
Delightful, cozy Irish pub, with live music on most nights. I went on open mic night, so the actual quality of the acts varied wildly, but I still had a lot of fun, mainly because the atmosphere is so welcoming and relaxing. Props to the bartender Gracie for making a complete stranger feel welcome on his first visit.
Owner is really nice. I went on a Monday night and they had an awesome group of musicians there.Food: 5/5
We snapped a photo of Brian because he was awesome! We were so thankful to find an Irish pub within walking distance from our hotel. The drink prices were some of the most reasonable we found over our weekend in NYC and Brian was one of the most friendliest bartenders. He was welcoming, hilarious and told us all about his time in NYC. The bar never got too crowded either and we were able to enjoy our conversation. He even played one of my favorite artists over the music. Just an all around great bar and we will definitely go back if and when we are ever in NYC again.
Stopped for a few drinks and the bartender was great . Very attentive and social. Definitely suggest stopping for a pint or two.Service: 5/5
very cute, underrated spot! way bigger than it looks from the outside and the owner is super sweet! good vibes
Cash only bar live music singer with guitar every night. Neighborhood Irish bar with pool table in the backService: 5/5
Went to Paddys two nights in a row in the middle of the week on an impromptu trip to new york for the wild card game. My husband loves irish pubs so naturally we found the one bar open late and had a blast talking with fellow customers and the bartenders Brian and Gracie. I highly recommend this place to everyone. Wholesome place. Was not busy when we went but I'm sure on the weekends its packed.