Pizza Man

Pizza man is a local favorite! They offer deals daily on the weekdays making family dinners more affordable. I love bringing visiting family and friends here. I’ve tried the thin crust, pan crust and deep dish, all being wonderful. Thin crust is their signature style and is always loaded with toppings. The service here is very hit or miss unfortunately. Great tiramisu as well! Below is the pan crust Carnivoro pizza and the deep dish pizza man special.

Oof...the pizza crust was like crispy, oily, pita crackers. Not sure if I got a gluten free crust. I didn't order one, but I have family members who are gluten free so I've partaken in a gf crust or two in my life. Gluten free or not, the crust ruined the pizza. The cheese in the curds was good, but a bit too greasy on the breading side of things. My daughter liked the spaghetti and meatball. Cheesecake was tasty. Wish I would have read recent reviews before ordering. While many reviews mentioned staff treatment, that has nothing to do with my review. The food was just not good.

Took the family here last night for an impromptu dinner and it was great! We got the garlic bread, crispy brussel sprouts, margarita pizza, and pumpkin spice cannolis. All was delicious! Service was fast and friendly and they were great with our toddler. Will be back!

Great deals! Cozy environment! Our baretender Colleen was spectacular and very fun! When in doubt, can't go wrong with spending some time here. Love the pizza and drink specials. Support local mke!

All I can say is just Wow! That was the worst pizza we've had in this state hands down and we waited over an hour to receive 2 small pizzas. Pizza crust was burnt, taste-less, and extremely salty not even positive how you can achieve such salty pizza. Will not be returning and it's a shame because this place used to be amazing.

I don't want to judge this place on it's buffet lunch, that is never the best showcase for a restaurant. But I will say, as buffets go, it was fine. Three pizza slice choices, a pasta dish, and two kind of salad garden and a sort of Caesar, garlic bread with marinara sauce. Arrival was not a good start. Four servers were visible on their phones, laptops, and just chatting but no one greeted me for several minutes. A hostess did finally approach and seat me. I was doing the buffet so I got my food and waited several more minutes for a server to arrive and take my drink order. He was very nice and attentive enough after he got to my booth. Pro tip: if you get $30 on an $18 bill, bring back change. If I was going to tip $10 I would have said "I'm set". I tried to get his attention to get change after he returned a ten and two ones for me but after a few minutes I had to leave. I felt bad leaving the $3 I could scrounge up in my bag but I tried. I may try it later with the full menu but I don't think I'll do the lunch before again. The setting was standard issue bar/pizza place; dark wood, high ceilings, long bar. Nice enough.

Really enjoy the pizza and the wild boar ravioli… creative cocktails… Earl did a great job as our server! Chef John made the ravioli this morning so it was super fresh. Chef John also took the time to deliver our food to our table.

Always heard they had great pizza so we took my son here for his birthday and they did not disappoint. Pizza was great and the four cheese ravioli with Alfredo sauce was incredible. Service was fast friendly and attentive. We will definitely be back.

We had just moved to Milwaukee only a couple days before our visit. Little did we know we would be finding an amazing pizza place. We stumbled in a Monday and enjoyed half off wine bottle with our pizza. The waitress was very informative and nice the whole time we were there. We definitely will be back soon. We got two pizzas but our favorite and what we will be ordering the next time we go is the Bianca! Who knew cream cheese could be on pizza and be so yummy! We booked with opentable and recommend doing this for weekends or Friday’s but it wasn’t too busy on a weekday dinner mealtime.

If you want a pizza that tastes like saltine crackers dipped in marinara, this is the place to go. I got the Margherita pizza- and I know this is a big statement- but it was the worst pizza I have ever had. Totally devoid of flavor, but with the added bonus of having a chalky feeling in your mouth from the crust. A Jack's frozen pizza in the microwave is better than this $16 lunchable. Appetizers were good though