facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Cakes by Casey

  1. East Amherst
  2. Amherst Bakery
  3. New Buffalo Bakery

Reviews, get directions and information for Cakes by Casey

Cakes by Casey

About

Hi Everyone!
Welcome to Cakes by Casey. I am Certified in Culinary, Baking & Pastry Arts. Bringing you custom cakes and deserts. My specialty is Cakes & Cupcakes. I also offer cookies, cake pops, pies and more ! I am a small business... very small, and Ev



"Kaylena Marie’s is a locally owned and operated cafe that specializes in homemade dishes, rustic baked goods, and gourmet desserts that are guaranteed to blow your mind."
Address: 6769 Tuscany lane, East Amherst, New York 14051
Phone: (716) 949-8853
Email: [email protected]
State: NY
City: East Amherst
Street Number: 6769 Tuscany lane
Zip Code: 14051
categories: wholesale bakery


Similar places near
Tim Hortons Tim Hortons 2 miles Located at 9590 Transit Rd, East Amherst, NY, Tim Hortons is the perfect place to go ...
LaLa's Sweet Treats LaLa's Sweet Treats 2 miles Custom cupcakes, cookies, and treats!
Genevieve's Cheesecakes & Bake Shop Genevieve's Cheesecakes & Bake Shop 2 miles Welcome to Genevieve's Cheesecakes & Bake Shop. Come in and try our famous cheesecake...
Tavern at Windsor Park Tavern at Windsor Park 3 miles We are Hometown Tavern specializing in English & American Cusine with a heavy emphasi...
Ohlson's Bakery & Cafe Ohlson's Bakery & Cafe 4 miles We are a quaint European bakery with a family history of baking. Our recipes are pass...
Le Metro Bakery Le Metro Bakery 4 miles
Bagel Jay's Bakery & Cafe Bagel Jay's Bakery & Cafe 4 miles
The Frosted Buffalo The Frosted Buffalo 5 miles The Frosted Buffalo specializes in unique treats for all types of events. Made with t...
A.s.bakery__ A.s.bakery__ 5 miles Desserts
Wolter's Bakery Wolter's Bakery 5 miles Wolter's Bakery, how may we help you? We are open Monday through Friday 6:30 an until...
Dessert deli Bakery Dessert deli Bakery 6 miles Dessert deli was established in 1987, one of the first gourmet bakeries serving Willi...
Dunkin' Donuts Dunkin' Donuts 6 miles Dunkin' Donuts is an all-day, everyday stop for coffee, breakfast, donuts, and baked ...
Petri Baking Products Petri Baking Products 7 miles
Hatties Bakery Hatties Bakery 7 miles
Baby Cakery Baby Cakery 7 miles Cakes, cupcakes, danishes, pastries...you name it, I make it! =D
Just Say Cheesecake Just Say Cheesecake 8 miles Bakery and Cafe! Home of the original Cheesecake Wedding Cake since 1990 offering hot...
Vin-Chet Bakery Vin-Chet Bakery 8 miles At Vin-Chet Bakery, we put the “good” back into gluten-free baked goods. Stop in toda...
Baked Buffalo Baked Buffalo 8 miles Cakes & Gourmet baked goods
Reviews
A perfect little bakery that has a blend of sweet and savory. Just had the focaccia egg and avocado breakfast sandwich Really good! Enjoyed the raspberry turnover too! A light breakfast with a sweet ending except I had the sweet in the beginning.
Cute place, had the Turkey Sandwich with cranberries and lemon zest mayo.... DELICIOUS! I was amazed at the size of the cinnamon roll, we split it for 4 people. It was delicious BUT, too much icing and it pains me to say that but wish I had a plain cinnamon roll with icing on the side.
I can’t believe we waited so long for this bakery to open. It was a total disappointment first of all not one picture or decoration on any walls plane and ugly. No tablecloths and you got your plastic silverware and napkins yourself out of a plastic container. There ere 2 kids behind the displays, witch were all messed up, no pretty plates or colored doilies, not a thing to show off their baked goods. Goopy looking cinnamon rolls and a lumpy looking Almond Ring , I was interested in for some outrageous price of $45.00 or $ 6.50 a piece. We were told to order food at the counter and showed were the menus were, after ordering p1salad and some sandwiches roll up s. We were given a bag of chips our lunch in a plastic container and cold coffee. Their were 5 of us and the girls said that the coffee was cold and awful, the waitress was asked to make a new pot. Reluctantly, she did & offered my friend a free cookie instead. This area is a goldmine have you never seen the Cookie Jar backery on Hallmark. The ladies meet their every day for coffee and cookies, it’s beautifully decorated and the waitress knows what everyone wants. We have been waiting for our place to come and chat, the men in the area go to Tim Hortons. I know I am just being silly, but after taking my friends to our new bakery, I was so upset and humiliated by what It looked like and the prices were outrageous. You are in the middle of a very beautiful area of homes and senior appointments, do you not want our business? We would love to have a very nice place to go. Please help our wish come true Sue
Not impressed. Small area to meet people to enjoy a leisurely coffee with a menu that is not very enticing. I had a breakfast sandwich that was rubbery, probably microwaved. Not much above eating at a fast food joint. Will not return. The wait staff were not overly polite. Really a huge disappointment.
Just ok. The coffees Americano, oat milk latte were not great. At this price point, everything should be excellent. Two meals, two drinks- expect to pay about $50. Just not a comfortable experience and nothing that made us want to go back.
My wife and I went to Kaylena Marie’s for breakfast. The atmosphere is rather uninviting. The baked goods looked tasty. The food was decent, but WAY overpriced. Drinks were forgettable. We won’t be coming back here. Spot Coffee down Transit is a much better option for breakfast and excellent coffee.
CAUTION FOR NONDAIRY PEOPLE- I stopped in earlier today with my family to get a drink and they wanted to try a cinnamon roll which they enjoyed. I cannot have milk, so I opted for a chai latte with oat milk, no warnings from the staff. After trying my drink it tasted kind of off, strange flavor, but figured it was an uncommon chai brand until I saw the powder in the cup. Asked the staff only to find out they use Oregon chai powder which contains milk. I’ve worked in coffee shops for years and always notified patrons of potential allergens like milk if they ordered non dairy base. Hopefully they can add this to their training or switch to a more common chai concentrate so no one else ends up in my situation.
New bakery, everyone trying it. I gave it two tries in 3 days, cin rolls dry, apple strusel cake - just ok and the simple brownie, very chocolate like - frosting bad - will not go there again. Expectations may have been too high but I'm a baker and was hopeful of something wonderful. Prices are high enough to expect that.
Not bad but the portions are ridiculously big. You should definitely share the pastries.
Nice friendly staff, very clean and massive portions! Place can get busy but worth the trip
Comment on this place

Cakes by Casey map

to add Cakes by Casey map to your website;



Copyright 2026 | All rights reserved.

You can use our top contact for adding and editing your business's information.
0.0053 Loaded in seconds