Carmine's Italian American Bakery

I always take a box of Rugalach for the guys when I get my car worked on. Was the only customer about 7 am. Placed my order. Was told they had no boxes only paper bags. Strike one. Paid a $13 bill price went up with a $20. She had no change? Strike two. She took my money and walked out the door. She was gone so long I didn't know if I got ripped off or she was coming back. She didn't say a word just left! I have an appointment an hour away and construction traffic on 17 to deal with... strike three. When I finally get on the road and sneak one out of the bag it's stale! Not even fresh. So disappointed. Should have known when the tray was a messy hodge podge instead of nicely arranged like when it's fresh. The main location in Middletown is great but this satellite location in Port has never really held a candle to the original. My first impression is always to question the sanitariness ? of the place...but I keep going back for the Rugalach. It's unlike any other.

Love cookies wish phone worked,so I can order a cake,think they should be open later during holidays.

Awesome Donuts and really good prices. Good service

What italian bakery doesn't do their own baking not worth the trip.

Good ole bakery where you can enjoy fresh Italian pastries

Always get best cannoli cakes

Great service and food

Family business, fresh bakery