Croton Colonial Restaurant & Diner

I was born in sleepy hollow ny and we moved when I was 6 months old. This place is so worth it, but the bacon is a little hard so you have to ask for soft if you like it that way. But this place is soon good.Food: 5/5

It’s been a while since I’ve been here and I forgot just how good this place is. Ordered the breakfast specials and I tip my hat to yall lol it was amazing and the perfect meal man was I satisfied!!! I will certainly be back as I’ve never had a bad meal from here breakfast lunch or dinner.Food: 5/5

Stopped by after our hike at the Croton Gorge Park, Sunday afternoon. They seemed really packed and busy yet we got seated almost immediately. Order was taken by very friendly young lady. Food came out pretty quickly and it was way over proportioned- in a good way. We ate as much as we could and still were able to take left overs home. I had lasagna and that came with salad and soup waitress recommended split pea- and it was delicious kiddos had a burger and chicken tenders. We left super happy, and satisfied. Overall all staff very nice and friendly- but huge kudos to the waitress. She definitely has made our day Kid-friendliness: Very friendly Parking: Parking available

Most fairly priced food in the county. Also, the food is always very fresh and well prepared. EX Photo: $10.99 for a huge 2 pieces of fish Vegetarian options: Lots of options Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly

Absolutely, positively cannot beat a waffle sundae... especially one created by the Maestro himself. Thank you !!Food: 5/5

Great food, great prices, very large number of options to choose from, large quantities, homely feeling, ample seating and parking. Strongly recommend. We went for lunch here and had western omelette, egg sandwich and spaghetti and meatballs. They all were quite good and came with sides like toast/fries. The kids menu actually has enough food for 2 kids and comes with milk/juice and cookie/pudding. Coffee is unlimited refills.

Top notch in every Aspect. Case and point. I had a 24 ounce steak for $25. This is absolutely phenomenal. Never have this Ever happened in my life before. Give it a try. Highly recommended

When my maternal relatives used to live in Peekskill NY, we would visit this place at times, especially since I’m from NYC. Let me tell you, their breakfast options and even the shrimp scampi pasta was delicious. I’d definitely would visit their again!Food: 5/5

It’s a diner Don’t stray too far around the menu Don’t get your hopes up and if you order the burger make sure to ask for it medium. Mine was raw and I asked for medium rare! Nice waiter tho

Stopped here with my family for a meal on 2/18/23. We were met with a warm welcome by the host, staff & wait staff, the owner is a wonderful man. Our server was very nice. All 4 of us opted for breakfast. The food is very good. I do have a request, would be awesome if you had country fried steak & eggs as an option or special. Other than that this establishment is worth returning to. Highly Recommended by a Culinarian & Foodie, tell them Charlie sent ya!