Pickerington Goodwill

This is a nice location! They have some cool finds. The people are nice. Some of the stuff is a little on the pricey side for thrift.

I used to love coming here, especially with the deals on the weekends. However, it has changed. I’m not sure if it’s a new management, but the sizes are no longer separated and it’s very depressing in that store.

They’re rude. I went to pay and she asked if I “wanted to pay with cash” and I said “I’d prefer to use my card” and she laughed and judgmentally looked at me and said “are you serious?” I said “if the question is if I’m serious, yes.” Then she left the counter after I paid and gave my my bag and walked away so I left. then she is screaming at me to come back and sign something. Train your people better.

This place used to price things reasonably prior to new management taking over and re doing the store. It is dis-heartening to walk in and see $79.99 for used pairs of shoes that were donated. I see a $39.99 used electric jar opener? Is this the Goodwill or the Greedwill. Nothing good coming out of this store unless you’re paying up for it. If you want cheaper shoes at $4.99 it looks like a dog chewed on them. The Greedwill needs to change their mission statement as it’s no longer affordable.

When my mom was near by goodwill she would sometimes pop by to get her some things. In 2019 this place was booming. People everywhere. Good and better toys. Bags. The place does not have any custom bags the last time i have been here so you would have to get your own if you wanted lost of things.

I just want to let everyone know that had a bad experience with Dakota, she is no longer with us. We have a new manager. Please visit us again.

It is good place to drop off your household donation. All drop off are at their back door on the back side of the building. Be sure to knock on the door. If you want a receipt for you donation, just asking them. If you come during their off hours, you may just drop it off by the door. Once I drop off a TV a old tube type, and they told me that they don't want it, it simply is too old, and I ended up just put into the dumpster. So don't even bring anything too old and obsolete items.

Very clean and orderly. Great prices and friendly staff.

They do not accept returns for any reason and will not inform you until you’ve already made the purchase. I was told that this specific goodwill is not affiliated with other goodwills, they are independently owned. Aside from that, ok selection at best.

Yes, it is on the small side, but still better than most. The items change regularly, they are clean and well organized. The staff is generally friendly. It is rare that I come here and don't find what I'm looking for- and more! The furniture store, which is separate, is not as good. I dinged my review a star for that. Also small, they don't seem to have room for much of a selection. I was also disturbed on one occasion by the staff playing loud, vulgar not for families or children! music which could be heard clearly throughout the store. This was some time ago, so perhaps the problem has been solved.