Pickwickian Tavern

We had reservations at 5pm for 5 on a Saturday. We were greeted at sat right away. Our drinks and food orders were taken within minutes. However, 30 mins had surpassed and we seen the same exact appetizers we ordered pass us by on 2 different occasions and be placed on other party's tables that were seated 10 to 15 minutes after us. It was almost to the point were I was going to pay for our drinks and leave. Instead we patiently waited and our apps and entrées started to arrive simultaneously. We had no complaints of the French onion soup and the wings. My surf and turf special was huge and definitely needed a hearty appetite to finish. The crab cake had a lot of filler but I didn't expect more due to the price point. Fyi all the food was reasonably priced. Our children had no complaints of their food. The bark on the rib entree was a little too hard to the point it was hard to cut with a steak knife. It did have a good flavor but didn't appeared to be smoked. None of the appetizer dishes were taken away for the entire duration. We had to flag our waiter down for refills, I wasn't offered a refill on my drink and it was empty within 20 minutes of arriving. Food rating gets a 3.5 star. My service was definitely a 2 outside of the initial greeting and seating which was very polite and prompt.

This is my go to for poutine when I’m not in Canada!! First couple times they made it with cheese curds. Lately they haven’t. But it’s still amazing especially when topped with their amazing smoked meats!! Their portions are huge. We got the poutine, pulled pork platter, and cheesy salmon pasta.Food: 5/5

Hidden Gem. Great food, Great Service. Daniel was friendly and attentive. Hard to satisfy a large family but this place does it. Cheese Curds are a crowd pleaser. CheeseSteak is tops with Fried Onions, Peppers, and Mushrooms. Ari's Favorite wrap is very good also. Beer is cold. Thanks to Uncle Joe's Inflation prices are up ever where. Venture out and enjoy.

Stopped briefly while out running errands. Had the smoked deviled eggs and wings mild just to get a baseline on first visit. Smoke added a nice nuance to the eggs. Their wings are medium sized that I personally prefer, not too small, and not giant drumstick high size. Wings are unbreaded and smoked which makes for juicy tender meat and nice smoke flavor, but could be construed as cheating if compared to other bar wing greats such as Golden Nugget or Jughandle. Mild sauce had good zing as well, not boring or bland. Good looking bar inside. Didn't have any, but a lot of the sandwiches on the menu looked good as well. Would definitely return.

The food here is phenomenal! The photo below is their burger with brisket on it. It’s HUGE! Whenever we take someone there for the first time we tell them they need to get this burger lol Their smoked wings are amazing. Fried cheese curds are chefs kiss. And their pomegranate mules? Sooo good! There is so much on their menu to love. The staff is nice. And I love the atmosphere.

This is a fun little place right on Rt 40. We started with Fried Pickles and Cheese Curds. The Cheese Curds were amazing and would highly recommend. My wife got the Pulled Pork Platter with Mac and Cheese. I got the Pulled Pork Sandwich. Both were really good, best Barbecue in the area. The place has fun decor and service was good. For the quality, the prices are very reasonable. Parking is ample but it's a dirt lot so keep that in mind.

Went there tonight with a party of 7. Server was awesome, top notch. Was always checking on us to see if we needed anything. Food was amazing. The only complaint was the music. The girl had a beautiful voice just way to loud. You could not even talk to the person next to you. Don't understand how the Manger or owner doesn't see this. Sad part is the girl could really sing but just to loud to understand. But will definitely go back. Food and service was great.

Had the fish & chips. So good. The only thing I didn't like was that they had a live band that was a little loud. But the singer had a nice voice. All in all I would go back.Food: 5/5

I really like this place the food is so good. The portions are huge! From the nachos and cheese curds to the burger cheese steak. Everything is really really good. But the flies.. They have to go! I feel like we swatted flies the whole entire time. That was pretty annoying. Our server was very nice and noticed the issue with the flies but nothing anyone could do

We always love when we go. Never bad experience. Only thing I might say is when live music, maybe it could be a little lower. Music always good but a little loud during meals. We have brought several new customers and always love it. We will be seeing you all again soon.Food: 5/5