Family Owned Italian Restaurant
Sweet Tomato’s is a family owned restaurant located in the heart of Shelter Island Heights. Brothers Jimi (Owner/General Manager) and Anthony Rando (Owner/Executive Chef) delight guests with a carefully curated menu featuring delicate & refined dishes created with the freshest local seasonal ingredients, providing for an extraordinary culinary experience with each visit.
This quaint and cozy eatery offers a warm & welcoming ambiance and a simple elegance reflective of traditional trattorias found in Italy. The earth-tone design elements feature an exposed brick pizza oven and intimate seating highlighted by simple candlelit tables, candle wall sconces and generous seating at the bar, on the front terrace and on the patio..
