Osteria Prime 151

TripAdvisor suggested us to try their bread pudding for desert and I did! That was amazing! Even though I was already full but I had to make a room for it. My favorite is the appetizer, eggplant dish. It was out of this world!!! Definitely the best I’ve ever had! Will definitely come back!

The restaurant is very nice and quaint. Very lovely atmosphere. The service was overwhelmingly delightful with the owner being so nice and welcoming. It was the first I ate there and he treated us as if he knew is for years. The food was over the top amazing and the lasagna one of the best I've ever had. Definitely going back and highly recommend.

THE BEST! If you're looking for authentic Italian food with fresh ingredients this is your go to spot. The lasagna is one of the tastiest I've ever had - this is a must when you go!! The owner V makes you feel part of the family, its an experience like no other. Dont walk, but run to make your reservation here!

Not a large menu, but the food was fresh. The lasagna looked amazing and the service was spot on. We were a little disappointed when we left because the owner kept hovering around our table to take our bill which was fine, but we had to say goodnight about 3 times before he acknowledged us. Didn't feel warm and fuzzy when we left.

Great, great food, and very entertaining chef/owner. A+

This restaurant is very special. They take traditional Italian food and put a unique spin on it. Very fresh. Everything's homemade. The lasagna is epic! The quality of everything we ordered was outstanding. Make your reservations now! You won't be sorry!

Food was so-so, waiters were very nice, manager was beyond rude. One of the entrees came to the table cold and one of the meals came swimming in butter even though the person who ordered it referenced no dairy In fairness, the other dairy-free meal was correct. The manager maybe he's the owner, too? was nasty. He rushed us out the door before we finished our coffee, angrily told us we didn't spend enough money we were a party of seven and everyone ordered a meal, and told us we sat there too long we were there less than two hours. Wont be going back there again.

Always delicious. Always a great experience. The owner is heavily vested in making sure the customer is enjoying a great experience. He is a true Italian Chef whose heart is kind and giving for anyone who steps through the doors of his establishment. It shows well in the cleanliness of his restaurant and the smiles of his customers! A can't miss experience if you are visiting or living in the Montclair area.

Outstanding creatively prepared food. First visit. Delightful host V! I had chicken scarpariello- wonderful and perfectly seasoned. I couldn’t try the pastas for allergic reasons but my dinner companions said the lasagna and the bolognese were the best they’ve ever had! We will definitely return.

Incredibly attentive service makes for an exceptional experience. The seafood salad was fresh and filled with flavor and the lasagna was the absolute best I’ve ever tasted. It was absolutely mind blowing. Me and my wife can’t wait to come back again!