Pete's Pizza

I’m very confused. There’s no cheese. Only sauce and it tastes like Campbells tomato soup. I have never in my life seen pizza served with no cheese. When we first opened the box I really thought they mixed the order up with someone who ordered a pie with no cheese. Actually couldn’t eat it and had to throw out. First time I’ve never enjoyed pizza. How does this guy have a pizza shop?

The best thing about moving back to NJ is my favorite childhood pizza place I drove an extra 20 minutes out of the way to treat myself! The pizza is delicious as always and the customer service is always great!Recommended dishesSicilian Pizza

Best Pizza in NJ the drive I make is well worth it! I call the pizza reversed pizza, cheese then sauce. My 2 year old nephew loves it. I have been going there over 30 years a diamond in the ruff.

I love there pizza, it is like a tomato pie. I ask for mine to be crispy. If I am at the Columbus Farmers Market, I am stopping at Pete's. Not as cheesy as other places. Oh and you have to try the birch beer! FYI that this place does not have water.

Absolutely worth the hour drive to this pizza joint. They stick out from all other pizza places. They bake their pizzas with the cheese THEN the sauce. It's in the shape of a rectangle. You can get a half pizza, piece or entire pie. Very affordable food. Love love love this delicious pizza .

This place has amazing Sicilian plain Sicilian pizza, easily one of the best I've ever had but a little heads up, I'm pretty sure that's all they have on there menu. It's take out inside of the Columbus flea market. It was 20 bucks for the pie which was a good amount of food and I loved it

Perfect amount of sauce, tons of flavor. I have been eating this pizza since I was 6 years old and I am now 28 years old. I eat pizza from here once or twice a month without failure. They are the best. Reasonably priced and lots of flavor in those square, saucy slices.

Fantastic square pizza! Delicious sauce and just the right amount of cheese on a crispy, chewy crust! Probably the best pizza in the Columbus Farmer's Market.

Great pizza. Best Square tomato slice in NJ. Service is lackluster but you don't go for service and ambianceFood: 5/5

I don't know what they do to their dough or their sauce but it is the best pizza I've ever had