Insomnia Cookies

Evening management here is so lovely; they're always very friendly and helpful when I come in. My only complaint is that occasionally I get weird-shaped half-cookies, but all of their cookies taste amazing! They're very respectful about bagging vegan cookies separately or boxing them separately, depending on how many you have, and their deluxe cookies are indeed deluxe-sized! see the deluxe cookie pictured P.S. the vegan birthday cake cookies are great even if you're not vegan! My personal favorite is the deluxe salted caramel.

Must sound very weird, but it was the first time in my 21 years on Earth to enter a cookie store past 10pm-ish, and it left such a good impression. I'm not a big fan of sweet eats, but this place downright convinced my heart and mind. I ordered a deluxe salted caramel for $4.28. Price was definitely not cheap, so minus - 1 star . Customer service was unexpectedly wonderful, given that nighttime staff elsewhere would typically feel reluctant to serve. They carefully asked if I wanted a paper plate or a double-open bag for takeout. Recalling all my cookie-tasting memories, I think this is the best cookie I have ever had. They handed the cookie to me lukewarm. First bite was exactly like described in the title, very ooey-gooey. You could feel that batter hot out of the oven melting in your mouth. The texture was soft, wet, a little crispy, and sticky; nothing could compare to it!! When I first held it, it broke into medium-sized parts that fit my chewing capacity. Yummy, but one is enough for the night because it's cloyingly sweet at some point. Please handle it with care, or it will break into pieces‼ Overall, very positive experience in my first attempt at ordering and tasting a cookie. Also feeling thankful because there was a suddenly long, long queue after my order ‍ P/s: Highly recommend for late-night sugar cravers!! Opening until 1AM

Freshest cookies in the Western New York area. Friendly staff! Cookie Monster likes to greet you as you wait for your order to be served hot and fresh! An experience of goodness all around. You won't be disappointed by the product you recieve!

The cookies were warm and delicious on this cold day. The customer service was amazing. They got us in and out. It's definitely worth the drive there.

This place is open late night and even drivers locally! I got a salted caramel deluxe cookie with 2 different delicious flavors of ice cream on top. 10/10 recommend!

I ordered delivery with an estimated time arrival time of 20 minutes. 2 hours later and I still had not received cookies. Order was cancelled.

As new customers, it was really surprising when the employee working a few nights ago was rude and impatient. Maybe it was just the employee or that night but not a pleasant experience and wouldn’t go here again. Got the ice cream and cookies and the cookies weren’t warm enough in my opinion.

I was looking for something sweet and can be delivered late in the day and weekend for my son birthday. Insomnia cookies Amherst MA happy to delivery 7 days a week. I ordered online paid for everything included delivery charge and the tip. I chose Insomniac Celebration Pack. A signature 6" cookie cake, a pint of ice cream, and a Super 6 pack. Add a brownies too.The delivery guy will text or call to let the recipient know when he/she arrived. My son when to the front door got the Cookies and ice-cream. Cookies still warm and fresh and the ice-cream still cold my son told me. He and his roommate enjoyed them very much. I will recommend for everyone.

Want cookies? Want late night cookies?! Great place to go with MANY options. Order in, take-out, or delivery via. store and mobile apps like doordash so no excuses

Online menu/ info is incorrect- price is 15$ for 6 cookies, not 11$, and much wider variety of flavors available than posted online. Cookies taste good though. They aren’t 4$ a cookie good though- just regular cookies.