Old Mill Tavern

This is our go-to place for wings. Although they have other food we are just die hard fans of their wings. There seems to be a lot of camaraderie here. We always meet people and are able to engage in conversations with them. It's nice to meet people from all over and to be able to communicate and meet people who will become friends. There is generally plenty of parking. However since this is a local hotspot sometimes it's touch and go. Kid-friendliness: Their motto is the more the merrier and that includes children. Parking: Since this is a local hidden gem, sometimes it's hard to find parking. But we are always more than willing to wait for a space to open up or park at a nearby park and walk.

This is a fun local watering hole. The Friday night band was good and people were dancing under the festive lights. The French dip sandwich was good as were the wings. Their suicide wings actually require a waiver and our son, who loves very hot wings, was satisfactorily impressed.

First time at this location with a party of 4. It was slow when we entered on a Sunday afternoon but was pretty filled up when leaving. Homemade fries, grilled cheese, steak sandwiches were tasty and reasonably priced. We enjoyed the decor & uniqueness of the place. We stayed inside though it would have been nice to listen to the music outside if there were shaded areas to sit at. Bathrooms were clean so we appreciated that. Had two people wait on us this day. Service was friendly but I had to go to the counter to pay after waiting patiently to pay the bill after 15-20 minutes. Tables around us were being served by other waitress. Maybe there was a shift change? After paying we did find our waiter smoking outside and he didn't say a word to us. Female waitress no where to be found. Communication could have been better. I would recommend this establishment. I hope the service is better next time around.

Awesome Wings! Great Grouper Sandwich as well. We've been here a couple times and will likely be back many more. The staff here is super friendly. Seems they have a lot of people that prefer to show up in Golf carts; however, there is plenty of parking for other vehicles off to the side parking lot. I look forward to coming when they have some live entertainment. Parking: Limited parking in the front, lots of parking off to the side. Seems they prefer Golf carts.

It was okay. The server, he was good. Wings okay. Thought sauces would be home made but doubt they were. Great home made potato chips. Got Greek salad dressing, don't think it was correct, had red wine vinegar in it.. Outside tables would look much better with a coat of paint. Online menu said Baby back ribs. Apparently only on Friday nights.

Went there for lunch on a Friday. Place had very few people. Waitress was fun and nice. Food took Forever but when it did come it was amazing! Everyone loved it

This is definitely a local hang out! If you’re looking for more of a bar scene with pubby food this is your place! We ate outside because we had our dog so you have to order at the bar but they do bring your food out to you. The wings and shrimp have a plethora of sauces and dry rubs you can add or combine. I ordered the grilled shrimp with garlic butter Cajun sauce. It was yummy but not grilled unless they meant flat top. The sweet potato fries weren’t crispy, a little soggy. My husband had the grouper sandwich, the batter was flavorful and crispy. Fries were just ok. Looks to be a fun place when there’s music.

You need to order inside if you are eating on the patio. The girls will bring out your order. There was live entertainment on Sunday evening. Our onion rings were overcooked but everything else was very good. My husband got blackened grouper sandwichexcellent, the ladies ordered crab cakes also very good!Food: 4/5

They had a band outdoors and a good fun crowd. We just stopped for drink and stayed an hour. Danced a little on the grass in front of the stage. Seems to be a local hangout. Lots of golf carts in the parking lot. I would go back again. Band ended at 9. Not fancy, but a fun place for sure. Locals were friendly.Food: 4/5

Nice roadhouse off the beaten path, seems more for locals than travelers. Good menu. Chicken wings were excellent as were the crispy style fries. Wife got a grouper sandwich that she enjoyed. Lots of outdoor seating. Will stop again.