Theo's Olive Oil

The staff were super helpful in creating a Christmas gift basket. They do the packaging and the shipping right at the store so it truly is a one-stop-shop. Most items in store are local to North Carolina which is a wonderful touch and makes supporting them easy.

This is the model small business. Small footprint, unlimited potential. How do they do it? POOC is rooted in quality. Quality products. Quality people. Tourists and locals alike appreciate both. And … by sharing recipes using the premium olive oil and balsamic vins, every customer walks away with inspired dishes to try at home.

I use the butter flavored oil multiple times a week, and I tell everyone I know who enjoys cooking about this place. In addition to a large assortment of flavors, they offer a loyalty program and a discount for returning bottles for refill.

Great experience!!! First time in and they treated my wife and I with fantastic customer service right from jump. From oil tastings to sampling the different balsamics, it was uber cool!!! The staff took the time to give us recipes for what we purchased and little hints like bottle refills & holiday gift bags. And they have many other items besides olive oils and balsamic vinegars. But, you have to go to this eclectic, little gem to discover all the unique treasures for yourself...we will be back again and again!!! Hint: Look for the pecan smoked maple syrup!!!

When we go to Pinehurst, we always stop here. Can try all kinds of olive oil and balsamic vinegar. The ladies inside are always super helpful in letting us know what flavor goes with what dish and makes the best suggestion’s.

Loving Cara Cara orange/vanilla balsamic vinegar paired with blood orange fused olive oil. Going back today to get an oil to pair with lavendar balsamic vinegar and explore more flavors. Fun place to shop!

Jamie and Susan were so helpful showing us the different olive oils and balsamic vinegars. They have delicious products and you can taste in store! They also provide affordable shipping out of state. Thank you for a great visit!

My sister was the first one to introduce me to their oils....wow! whata find!! We've since ordered several different kinds and haven't been disappointed yet....I especially like it on fresh veggies and just roast in the oven.......makes great gifts too!

Love all of the choices in this store. There’s so many oils and balsamics to choose from and they send emails with recipes for the flavored oils. My favorites are the garlic olive oil and I love the coconut balsamic.

Kim was the star of the store! So kind and personable, we could have stood all day and talked with her. I purchased and also highly suggest the key lime white balsamic vinegar. It delivers the perfect summer tang to any salad! I will be back for more bottles of olive oil goodness the next time I visit Pinehurst!