Baby Tommy's Taste of New York

Listen, it’s not bad. It’s not amazing, either. The crust/dough is a bit on the sweet side for my taste but the texture is pretty good. Nice and thin like a NY slice should be. Crust is crispy, but again, sweet. Sauce isnt sweet or overbearing, more Tart, thank goodness. Cheese…could use a smidge more. Crust doesn’t hold up when held up, if you know what I mean gibbagoabbagool oh!

Easily miss if you drive by for the first time. I came here for something easy for lunch. Got ziti with sausage; rich and flavorful in generous portion. Side salad was crisp and clean. Pricing is acceptable for year 2022. I will be here if I’m in the area.

Probably a 3.5 but I rounded up since I don't know of another slice spot in the area and that is a nice feature. Good, but not spectacular. The service was good, I was greeted and got my order pretty quickly. What I ordered: BBQ Chicken Pizza Medium $22.49 Choose your own, Cheese + Sundried Tomatoes Medium $19.99 The crust was foldable while still having some strength. It had no flavor on it's own but held up to the toppings. Neither of my pizza's were cut all the way through, so a knife or your own cutter required or tearing it which is not easy when doling out quickly. One of the slices had a hole in the crust, so it was just toppings on parchment. The red sauce was good nothing overpowering. The BBQ sauce was listed on the website as "tangy", it wasn't just very sweet. This isn't a bad thing but if you were expecting tangy you didn't get it. I would bet $ it is Sweet Baby Rays, so if you like super sweet style its great. Cheese amount was good, didnt taste much cheddar on the BBQ but it was fine. A lot of sundried tomatoes! a huge plus. The star of the show was the chicken cutlets used on the BBQ chicken pizza. I think if would be just as good if not better to get a cutlet sandwich w/BBQ sauce and some peppers & onions.

Calzones are huge and delicious. It’s enough for two or for 1 with leftovers. Cheesy bread and brownies were also great. Staff are super nice, patient, and generous. Seasonings on every table so you can add as much spice and garlic as you like. Very filling and a great quiet little place to enjoy some good food! Hope to be back soon.

I eat here every couple weeks or so, it's my favorite pizza place around! Good value for the price, and the staff is always nice.Dine in: YesOutdoor seating: YesTakeout: YesDelivery: YesCurbside pickup: No

UPDATED: Delicious! As someone from Buffalo, NY where there's a mom and pop pizza shop on every corner, this took me bake home. Love this place! 2 slices of pep, a drink and a blue cheese for the crust. As it should be! UPDATE: They've remodeled the whole place! Had to do a double take. Looks great!

My mom and I have been coming here for almost a decade. This is the real deal, best damn pizza in Marietta. Every time you walk in the door the staff is super friendly and welcoming and will go Above and Beyond in everything they do. You can seriously tell they love their job and have a blast doing it. The slices are huge and their pasta portions are two meals for me.

Wonderful staff today we met I took training class today and upon arriving to restaurant We ordered double sided meat lovers and ultimate veggie pizza double sided, we were prompted by Manager named Derrick I do believe low haircut and of melanin descent somewhat older male…..the whole complete staff was very supportive and helpful. Keep up good work. I loved the pizza and the cheese rolls they come with sauce side too

This is the BEST pizza around. The crust is wonderful. There are so many items on their board that you could eat there everyday and not get bored. The hotdog is next on my list to try. They look amazing. And the new owners are great! So passionate.

Very easy to miss. I had low expectations coming in and I have to say I was disappointed… in myself for underestimating the food and only getting 2 slices. Since then I have been back twice and am always satisfied. Well deserved title of best pizza in Marietta