Inatteso Pizzabar Casano

I really had a extremely bad experience here. For the steak, I asked for median rare. The inside is like that but see the outside, it is overcooked and it tastes really bitter. I asked the waiter and he just said that It is median rare and did not answer my question of the reason why this steak taste soft inside but bitter and hard to chew outside. He said that it was nonsense and he went away with a frustrated emotion. Non of the employee helps us. We ate the meals reluctantly for the reason that we did not want to waste the money that we spend. Moreover, the chicken is sour and all the meals are not delicious at all. What in the world is this? I am really hungry but I did not say anything because I didn’t want to disseminate the negative feelings to other customers.

Absolutely incredible! The restaurant had a wonderful ambiance, the food had beautiful flavor and the staff… AMAZING! 10/10Food: 5/5

Despite the location, the restaurant does not feel like a tourist trap. Food was very good - the ragu was meaty, tagliatelle was cooked well, the pizza was well made and well cooked. The bianca sauce was hearty with a great balance of cheese and mushroom flavours. Service was great too!

Very friendly welcoming service from the team. Very different from the grumpy rude guy from last year. Pizzas were huge, of quality and yummy. Great chewy and crunchy crust. Very generous on basil unlike other places that you get 1 leaf as a decoration. Vegan option was avail as well. Snag a window seat area especially at lunch as main dining room seemed too dark. Nice decor all around.

Inatteso is a neighborhood gem! Can’t stop going back to this place. The food is delicious & fresh and the wait staff are very nice. Can’t beat the outdoor patio too. It looks like they are renovating the inside which is very exciting because I know I’ll be back in the colder months.Food: 5/5

This is probably hands down the best pizza and appetizers I have had second to my time in Italy. Great service and phenomenal appetizers, drinks, and food. Thank you for a fantastic meal our first time in New York!

Absolutely loved it! It’s a hidden gem! My sister lives few blocks away and she wanted us to try this place and we loved it! The service was absolutely amazing and the food came out fresh and delicious! They have plenty of seating, beautiful bar area, one of the best pizza places in NYC!

Really good pizza. Very solid crust. The cheese on the margherita was the perfect amount of browned and chewy. The salad either the carro and fennel was tasty. Great patio. the servers were all warm and friendly even though we had a very vocal 2 year old. Will eat againFood: 5/5

I had a wonderful experience at the newly refreshed Inatesso, the food was delicious especially the Toscano pizza, our steak was perfectly cooked and we added the crispy rosemary potatoes for good measure. Casual upscale dining is hard to get right but they got it just right. I would return & recommend to friends.

at first bite I knew it was the best tasting pizza I've tried in a long, long time. Their meatballs are auperb, nothing fancy- just savory meatballs. Each ingredient in the pizza is special. Hard to describe. We were pleasantly surprised when we found this place. Compliments to the chef!