Katzinger's Delicatessen

I was so excited to try lunch here that I made a special trip. Was disappointed that there was nowhere to sit inside to eat and that everything was to go. Thankfully a table with two ladies let me sit with them in the shade outside before my red headed self burst into flames. I got the large Reuben, original potato salad and cherry cheesecake. The Reuben was incredible. Generous amount of meat, the sauerkraut was not overwhelming and it was beautifully toasted. The prices were extremely fair and the staff was very nice. Will definitely go back when it cools off a little.

Food is good but not worth the wait. My family of 4 stood in line to order for 10+ minutes. I get it you’re busy but then it was another 20+ minutes for our food. We ordered desserts and sandwiches. We ate the sandwiches outside because of no indoor seating. We thought we had all the desserts because they were in a big bag. When we got back to the hotel and opened the bag a slice of pie and a brownie was missing. I called and they refunded me for the pie and didn’t even have the brownie on their receipt. The cashier repeated the order back to me and said everything so I don’t know what happened. Again good food but not worth the wait for sandwiches. We threw the pickles away because they had a weird taste and not like cucumbers.

The food was amazing! 5 for it. Got #36 loved every bite But atmosphere and place needs to be open for inside seating. No excuse for COVID. Paying premium at least need spot to seat and eat in this winter.Food: 5/5

Amazing experience at Katzinger's - Monica was super friendly and helped our first time experience be a wonderful one. We got the #1 and #70 sandwiches, latkes, knish, focaccia, red dragon mustard cheese, the cave age cheese, and a loaf of the harvest grain. Free pickles while you wait! Besides the food, the atmosphere of great with amazing houseplants. One of the best monstera I have ever seen! All in all, great experience and we will be back. Thank you Monica for your help!

This place is a solid 4.5 in my book. The service was awesome. The lady at the front who took our order was very nice, she even let us try one of the small pastry things like a fig newton. On to the food, my wife got the #1 and i got the #39 i believe. For 15$ i was kinda expecting a Carnegie Deli style monster sandwich but what i got was what I would consider a normal sized sandwich. They were both very good. We got the greek salad and pasta salad and both were decent. The greek could use quite a bit more dressing. I know the pickles seem to be a big star, but we weren't a fan of either the dill or garlic. To be fair, we really like claussen pickles in the refrigerator section, just for comparison. We will definitely be coming back though! Thanks guys and gals!

Awesome Deli!! People were great and the food was delicious and comforting with old world feel. They have assortment of cheese, meats and breads and much more. Not much parking around the area but we were lucky enough to get the spot in front of the store. We had the Reuben, marinated herring, latke, and motzo soup. I also learned that Bill Clinton had visited this establishment as I seen his pics on the wall.

Both sandwiches were fantastic! Well done Katzinger’s!! We ask for #37 & 76. Man excellent place for a good sandwich/ delicatessen

We live a stretch south of Columbus so we don't get into the city that often. Since we were going to be close by we planned to pick up Katzinger's and bring it back home to have with some friends. The place was busy as usual. We placed the order as usual, it was repeated back and sounded mostly correct. We corrected it and the cashier said he got the changes and hurried us on. When we got our food and pickles for everyone, we looked to make sure we had the right number of containers and sandwiches and the right numbers from the menu were on the sandwiches that weren't customized, we headed for home. When we got there we found that we probably should have unwrapped each one and checked it. Sandwiches that normally have 2 meats only had one. Condiments were wrong. Some had the wrong meats all together. Most of the group wouldn't eat the pickles as they were said to have a weird chemical taste. There was something wrong with every sandwich but one and that person felt guilty for enjoying the sandwich while everyone else was disappointed. I felt guilty for recommending the restaurant so highly and talking everyone into it. The person who got the correct sandwich was really happy with it. Several of us still felt the sandwiches were tasty even though they weren't correct. One was mad, and we had to make new sandwich for one who wouldn't eat what he got that wasn't even close to what was ordered. I know they're probably understaffed like everyone else, and they were very busy. But every other time I've been there they've been very busy and I've never had an experience like this. I do feel like I checked the order within reason before we left and I don't expect that having to unwrap every sandwich at the restaurant to make sure it's made correctly is reasonable. I would still go back because I've had so many good experiences that outweighed this one. However I know I won't be able to get anyone else in that group to go back with me, which makes me pretty sad.

Downtown staple that has managed to keep prices from rising while still providing g a very good product. Karl's Killer club was a massive sandwich with good flavor

Love the food, pricing wasn't a big shock as im from NY and see those prices every day, but it was well worth it. Food was excellent and served up quickly.Food: 5/5