Caribou Tavern

I'm fine with standoffish bartenders who don't treat you that nice to a degree, but my experience at the Caribou really sucked. I hate this bar... And it keeps ending up on everyone's list of favorite bars, which completely mystifies me! I went there a year ago with some colleagues. A couple of us ordered an IPA on tap that was awful and undrinkable. We asked for a different beer after a couple sips, which was met by the bartender with a roll of the eyes. We were charged for those beers that we didn't drink. When we asked to have them removed, our polite request was met with even more disdain from the bartender. I can't remember if we ended up paying for them because the look is what stuck in my head. Also, another friend felt guilty or shamed or something and left a $20 tip, which wasn't deserved. I've never gone back, and I don't intend to.
1 9 years ago (13-05-2018)

The bartender here is very considerate and actually wouldn't let our guy friend order us drinks because he wasn't sure if we were a group (excellent safety precaution)! Great atmosphere if not a little crowded, but what else do you expect from a small hole in the wall bar.
5 8 years ago (28-05-2018)

Winslow is the best. He is always relaxed and never buckles under pressure. He never fails to take care of his patrons. The food is great and not expensive, along with the drinks. If you are in Madison and not at the bou, you're missing out!
5 9 years ago (25-03-2018)

The best neighborhood bar in Madison in my opinion. I have been a part of their family for years and this locale is what makes Madison for me. Comfortable when you go to eat during the day and always inviting with great food. An exuberant crowd during appropriate times which will leave you wanting to return again and again. This was my first real taste of Madison and I wouldn't trade it for anything.
5 9 years ago (16-02-2018)

Good service and food, even when they were busy...6:30 on a Sunday evening...and there was only a stool or two empty. Definitely on our radar and will stop again when in Madison and want a good burger.
5 9 years ago (01-05-2018)