Spicy Pie Pizza | South Fargo

I love Spicy Pie, the food is fantastic! This is a great place to get food with some friends after a concert or a game. The atmosphere is good and usually family friendly. The food comes out in a timely fashion, so there is never too long of a wait unless it's busy. I'd say pricing is low to mid range as well which is good. A group of friends can easily share one of their large pies and a side of some sort. My favorite menu item is the bread bites!
5 7 years ago (03-12-2017)

I live near this location and have repeatedly tried to give it a chance, but I won't eat here anymore. The food is just not made well and delivery is bad. Last order was crushed to the point the subs we're completely flattened and therefore soggy. Boneless wings are just deep-fried chicken cubes with no breading. Most of the pizza toppings taste off and the pizza is frequently undercooked.
1 7 years ago (04-12-2017)

Tonight's experience was good although we've had slow service in the past. Enjoyed The Spicy Pie - it wasn't as spicy as the write up would lead you to believe and had good flavor. I also have a big sweet tooth, so enjoyed a dessert knot with cream cheese after pizza.
3 7 years ago (07-11-2017)

Ordered two grinders to go, waited an hour. Payed 30$ for the 2 and a bread bite and a toastada. Last time I went there they gave my pizza to the wrong person. Garbage. Don't go there
1 7 years ago (09-02-2018)

Pizza that comes without sauce or cheese? If you want these items on it make sure you request it or you won't get it. That's what happened to me when ordering a choose your own toppings. I thought those two things were a given on pizza. Edit. I decided to give Spicy Pie another try after my bad experience. I offered & paid online & my girlfriend stopped to pick up the pizza on her way home. Apparently she was sharing the story about our last order not having sauce or cheese. The employee checked our pies before she turned them over & the pepperoni pizza had no pepperoni on it! One topping & they couldn't get that right! I also had emailed the owner in response to the comment on my initial review (see below) about wanting to make things right. It's been a couple of weeks & I've yet to hear back. I can only conclude that not only are the employees incapable of performing a fairly simple job (I worked at a pizza place once upon a time), but the owners are aware & don't care. Because of all of this I must say this is one of the worst food places I've ever been to & that's unfortunate because the pizza is very good if they can make it correctly.
1 8 years ago (09-07-2017)