St. Paul Fish Company

Lobster roll was not good. They forgot the sauce. It was my first time having one so I did not know what to expect. So I come here and look at the pictures... Did not look like that at all. NO SAUCE.
1 8 years ago (14-05-2018)

The open market atmosphere should have helped with our first dining experience here. The food was as expected. I had the lobster dinner and my husband had the lobster roll. He said his was good... my food was as expected. We would've had a much better experience had the staff been less mopey and more engaging. Duds all of them ... i expected better so it tempered the review of my lunch quality. We had a 70 dollar bill but not enough fun to justify going back there.
2 9 years ago (17-01-2018)

Worth the wait, order the Lobster Roll and Oysters. Review is for Dine in Only, no comment on retail. This place is a part of the Milwaukee Public Market. Put your name down when you get there and explore the Market until your table is ready. Super reasonable prices for seafood. Lobster roll is $15 and the roll is stuffed with lobster. East Coast Virginica oysters start at $1.5 per but that's the same price as getting unshucked ones from Austin, TX in a grocery store
5 8 years ago (09-05-2018)

The BEST damn lobster roll I have ever eaten! We went to this establishment last September and didn't realize how FREAKING AWESOME their lobster roll was until we tried others! I would make a second trip to Wisconsin just to have this lobster roll again!
5 8 years ago (28-04-2018)

Great sit down eatery. Also have reasonably priced seafood. The lobster dinner is great. Used to be a great deal, now it's an ok deal. Thursdays after 4 you can get half price on bluepointb oysters.
4 8 years ago (19-05-2018)