Holey Cream

I mean a donut ice cream sandwich??? This is a gem! Super duper sweet but perfect for that sugar craving or late night sweet tooth. They have a wide variety of desserts here and I really did enjoy my donut sandwich even though I couldn’t finish it! Would come back!
4 7 years ago (23-05-2018)

I love their oatmeal raisin ice cream, which they’ve finally brought back after getting rid of it for a while. The customer service usually leaves a lot to be desired, but I still keep going for that delicious ice cream. I’ve never tried any pastries, cookies, or the doughnut ice cream sandwich.
4 7 years ago (05-06-2018)

Walked from midtown to Hell's Kitchen tonight to find the Holey Cream. We ordered a donut ice cream sandwich with cookies and cream ice cream and chocolate frosting. It was served in a shallow plastic clamshell that made it difficult to eat and dripped on my pants as the ice cream melted. The doughnut was thin and bland. Ice cream was pretty average and far from the best available in New York. I'll pass on Holey Cream next time and recommend you skip it too.
2 7 years ago (30-05-2018)

The holey moley flavor was awesome! My husband had the donut sandwich and it was good as well. Fast service and reasonable prices.
5 7 years ago (29-04-2018)

Ice cream was good. Service was good, but slow. Cupcake was subpar and tasted of plastic. Had to throw it away.
2 7 years ago (30-05-2018)