The Penny Ice Creamery

What a sweet place! It was a hot day and I was passing through town with some friends, I'm so glad we stopped here! The ice cream options were great, with a variety ranging from vanilla to rose petal nectarine. I'm a cone person and the cones were so tasty and crisp! Plus super fun and unique toppings, yes please! There's indoor and outdoor seating as well, so you can chill and enjoy a nice sundae (or two).
4 7 years ago (02-06-2018)

LOVE LOVE LOVE this ice cream place. 😍😍😍. I wish I live nearby and I'm glad we visited this place. The toasted marshmallow fluff topping was one of the reason we stopped by this ice cream place and it did not disappoint. They torch there fluff to order. I ordered the Tahitian vanilla bean ice cream with the fluff and it was the best thing ever!!! Looking back at the picture I wished I'd ordered the cone as well. My friend ordered the sorbet which was good as well. I'd come back here again for the fluff!
5 8 years ago (14-04-2018)

The shop might be slightly hard to find sometimes. Cozy inside and patio seats for people that would to sit outside. They are a sponsor of the local D-League basketball team (Santa Cruz Warriors). So gets packed after the game is done. The price might be slightly high for some people but is completely worth it. All the flavors are seasonal so don't expect to get the same one different visits.
5 8 years ago (30-03-2018)

The toasted marshmallow topping is something new and unique to this place you got to try it. The serving size is also huge so careful of the scoops. Small place. They make their ice cream in that place and not some random factory making it non preserves etc. And you can also see some of the machines that make them.
5 7 years ago (14-05-2018)

(Warning: young adults from Central Florida in for vacation) There’s a good reason there’s always a line into this little establishment: This place proudly makes ORGANIC ICE CREAM AND TYPICALLY HAS A VEGAN OPTION. Plus that instagram-worthy, burnt marshmallow topping helps. Penny’s only serves a dozen or so flavors, but they do those flavors really well. MY MEYER LEMON POPPY SEED SCOOP ATOP A GREEN TEA SCOOP was a delicious combination. The Lemon’s flavor wasn’t too sour, but a good mix of sweet and citrus. The Green Tea’s flavor was more delicate-- almost like vanilla with a hint of green tea. Even a scoop of good ol’ Cookies and Cream yielded a great blend of cookies and creamy vanilla. Every flavor and texture went well with the crunch OF THEIR HOUSEMADE CONES. While waiting in line, A SMALL BOARD OUTSIDE SHOWS THE FLAVORS so you don’t have to try and peer above people’s heads for the menu behind the counter.
5 7 years ago (26-05-2018)