American Cut

The atmosphere is very upscale, matching the impeccable service you are provided with. Prices are what they are, but the food is great. My only gripe is the wine is bottle only, and the sides are smaller than expected. However, I enjoyed my time there.
4 7 years ago (10-04-2018)

I really wanted to like this place. We came with a party of 5 and had great things. I thought the food was mediocre and overpriced, for what we got. My girlfriend's Filet mignon was not at all tender and it was overcooked. She asked for it medium rare. Came out more like medium well. My short rib was bland and tasteless. The chili lobster was OK, but for the $34 price or wherever we paid, you hardly get any meat. Not to mention glasses of wine are $16. The wait staff was friendly and the food was served in a timely manner, but overall I was not impressed.
3 7 years ago (30-05-2018)

Hands down, share the tomahawk! Presentation with fire at the table. Not your traditional joint where staff thinks they're doing you a favor. Great service. Great food. Great vibe. Wine list with an option for everyone. Make a reservation. Try the caramekized carrot as a side dish - it's an eye candy.
5 7 years ago (15-03-2018)

I know this is a steak place but if you come here you have to get the pretzel with a smokey old fashioned. Delicious and you'll feel good with two.
5 7 years ago (10-05-2018)

We tried this place one night and were so impressed we cancelled reservations at another restaurant and came back the next night! The food is amazing and the service was top notch!! Jared was our waiter and we loved him!! He went above and beyond and our whole family just had a fun time with him! This is a must try in NY. We will be back for sure!
5 7 years ago (02-01-2018)