Reilley's North End Pub

The cottage pie is pretty much what I imagine is served in the great hall of Valhalla. It's a mound of meat, potatoes, cheese, and peas that could satisfy the likes of this himself. Pairs nicely with a pint of Guinness. Went on a slow night, food was made quickly, but the server disappeared for quite a bit at one point. I'm sure he was just dealing with someone else we couldn't see, but when you're hungry and the server disappears before you can order food you get kind of impatient. Overall 4 out of 5, great food, drinks, and atmosphere.
4 8 years ago (29-05-2018)

The best bartenders and servers on the island. Food is incredible. And a great happy hour in the bar.
5 8 years ago (27-05-2018)

Definitely a locals hang. Monday is $14.95 lobster night and you need a reservation in advance. She had the lobster and I had cottage pie, a knockoff of shepherds pie. Food was great, prices were good, but atmosphere was definitely locals.
4 8 years ago (19-02-2018)

Great sandwich. Quiet atmosphere for a business lunch.
4 8 years ago (22-04-2018)

Food was wonderful. Atmosphere was comfortable . Service was fair. Hot horseradish hit the spot with dinner.
4 9 years ago (31-01-2018)