OddFellows Ice Cream Co. The Parlor

So good. I loved their interesting flavors. The waffle cone was fresh and had a perfect light and crispy texture. I tried Pecan pie and buttermilk honey blueberry. Both flavors were very good, not too sweet with a perfect creaminess. But you could tell there were no artificial stabilizers. The ice cream had the faintest hint of tiny ice crystals. Not enough to be unpleasant, just enough to be sure the stuff is real and made in house.
5 8 years ago (31-05-2018)

This is one of my favorite ice cream parlor. The ice cream and home made waffle cones are great. There are different flavors everyday, some are better than others. My favorite is the Chocolate Chunk. It can be a little on the pricey side, a waffle cone with two scoop will cost you $8.50 - but hey its Williamsburg and rent has to get paid.
4 8 years ago (27-05-2018)

Great ice cream spot. The design and layout of this shop is very cute. The sprinkles ice cream hits the spot every time. Each and every individual ice cream scoop is sure to melt your tongue away. Delicious. If I could, I would buy a pint every single day!
5 9 years ago (01-05-2018)

They always change the variety of flavors! They keep the basic ones like rainbow, and vanilla & chocolate. You can give them a call beforehand and they will tell you which flavors they have available. It’s also right next to the piers so you can enjoy your ice cream with a beautiful view.
5 9 years ago (26-04-2018)

My family and I adore OddFellows Ice Cream. Unique flavors. Only downfall is there is usually a line out the door, but it is definitely worth the wait.
5 8 years ago (31-05-2018)